"If you copy then it is not self-expression"
About this Quote
In a culture where guitarists can learn a solo note-for-note in under an hour, Schenker’s line lands like a hard palm on the fretboard: technique is cheap, identity isn’t. Coming from a musician whose reputation was forged on a distinct melodic phrasing and tone, the intent reads as protective, almost territorial. He’s not attacking learning; he’s drawing a boundary between apprenticeship and artistry, between fluency and voice.
The subtext is an anxiety about what rock music used to promise: that sound could function like a fingerprint. Copying, in Schenker’s framing, doesn’t just borrow licks; it borrows the risk. Self-expression requires exposure, the willingness to play something that might be awkward or “wrong” because it’s yours. Mimicry offers the opposite bargain: approval without vulnerability, a ready-made identity you can wear onstage.
Context matters. Schenker comes out of an era when players developed in scenes, not feeds, and when gear, access, and even geography shaped individuality. Today’s hyper-documented music internet flattens those constraints, making influence more immediate and imitation more tempting. His quote pushes back against that convenience. It’s also a subtle critique of audience expectations: fans often reward perfect replicas of familiar styles, which trains musicians to prioritize fidelity over discovery.
There’s a tough-love ethic here: steal to learn, sure, but don’t confuse rehearsal with revelation. The real work starts when the copying ends.
The subtext is an anxiety about what rock music used to promise: that sound could function like a fingerprint. Copying, in Schenker’s framing, doesn’t just borrow licks; it borrows the risk. Self-expression requires exposure, the willingness to play something that might be awkward or “wrong” because it’s yours. Mimicry offers the opposite bargain: approval without vulnerability, a ready-made identity you can wear onstage.
Context matters. Schenker comes out of an era when players developed in scenes, not feeds, and when gear, access, and even geography shaped individuality. Today’s hyper-documented music internet flattens those constraints, making influence more immediate and imitation more tempting. His quote pushes back against that convenience. It’s also a subtle critique of audience expectations: fans often reward perfect replicas of familiar styles, which trains musicians to prioritize fidelity over discovery.
There’s a tough-love ethic here: steal to learn, sure, but don’t confuse rehearsal with revelation. The real work starts when the copying ends.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Michael
Add to List






