"If you don't have an E-mail address, you're in the Netherworld. If you don't have your own World Wide Web page, you're a nobody"
About this Quote
Stoll’s line lands like a campy prophecy, half warning label and half roast. The exaggeration is the point: “Netherworld” and “nobody” aren’t literal diagnoses, they’re social verdicts. He’s capturing the moment when a tool stops being optional and starts acting like a passport. Once that shift happens, it’s not just about communication efficiency; it’s about legitimacy. You exist to institutions, employers, communities, even friends, to the extent that you can be reached and indexed.
The subtext is a critique of how quickly “access” mutates into “obligation.” Email isn’t framed as a convenience but as baseline citizenship in an emerging digital public square. The web page, especially, signals the early internet’s ideology: selfhood as a homepage, identity as something you publish, brand, and maintain. Stoll is needling that utopian promise of democratized expression by pointing out its darker twin: a new hierarchy where visibility equals value.
Context matters. Coming out of the 1990s internet boom, when schools, offices, and governments were racing online, the quote reads as both reportage and alarm. Stoll (often skeptical of techno-hype) is tracking how network culture quietly rewires power: gatekeeping doesn’t disappear, it changes form. If your life can’t be emailed, searched, or clicked, it becomes administratively inconvenient and socially suspicious.
What makes the line work is its blunt binary. It dramatizes how a supposedly liberating technology can produce a new kind of loneliness: not being disconnected, but being treated as if you’re not really there.
The subtext is a critique of how quickly “access” mutates into “obligation.” Email isn’t framed as a convenience but as baseline citizenship in an emerging digital public square. The web page, especially, signals the early internet’s ideology: selfhood as a homepage, identity as something you publish, brand, and maintain. Stoll is needling that utopian promise of democratized expression by pointing out its darker twin: a new hierarchy where visibility equals value.
Context matters. Coming out of the 1990s internet boom, when schools, offices, and governments were racing online, the quote reads as both reportage and alarm. Stoll (often skeptical of techno-hype) is tracking how network culture quietly rewires power: gatekeeping doesn’t disappear, it changes form. If your life can’t be emailed, searched, or clicked, it becomes administratively inconvenient and socially suspicious.
What makes the line work is its blunt binary. It dramatizes how a supposedly liberating technology can produce a new kind of loneliness: not being disconnected, but being treated as if you’re not really there.
Quote Details
| Topic | Internet |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Clifford
Add to List







