"If you'll think about various series you've read, can you think of any instance in which, say, the tenth volume of the series is notably better than the first nine? I can't"
About this Quote
Perry is doing a neat bit of cultural deflation here: puncturing the prestige we automatically grant to sheer longevity. The setup is conversational, almost friendly ("If you'll think about..."), but it’s a trap door. He invites you to supply counterexamples, then lands the punchline with the blunt, shrugged-off "I can't". That final clause isn’t just personal preference; it’s a verdict on how series culture tends to work once it survives long enough to reach a tenth installment.
The intent feels less like dunking on books than questioning an industry logic that rewards continuation over culmination. A tenth volume implies success, a reliable audience, a machine that knows how to keep feeding itself. Perry’s subtext is that the machine usually gets better at maintenance, not at risk. Early entries have the urgency of discovery: the author is proving the world, the tone, the stakes. By volume ten, the incentives flip. Familiarity becomes the product, and novelty becomes a liability.
As a musician, Perry’s perspective tracks with how audiences talk about bands: the debut has hunger, the breakthrough has spark, the late catalog has "craft". Craft is real, but it rarely feels "notably better" because it often arrives alongside calcification - safe structures, recycled motifs, fan-service callbacks. The quote works because it frames that dynamic as a simple readerly test, then exposes how hard it is to pass. It’s less anti-series than anti-complacency: a warning that repetition, once profitable, starts masquerading as evolution.
The intent feels less like dunking on books than questioning an industry logic that rewards continuation over culmination. A tenth volume implies success, a reliable audience, a machine that knows how to keep feeding itself. Perry’s subtext is that the machine usually gets better at maintenance, not at risk. Early entries have the urgency of discovery: the author is proving the world, the tone, the stakes. By volume ten, the incentives flip. Familiarity becomes the product, and novelty becomes a liability.
As a musician, Perry’s perspective tracks with how audiences talk about bands: the debut has hunger, the breakthrough has spark, the late catalog has "craft". Craft is real, but it rarely feels "notably better" because it often arrives alongside calcification - safe structures, recycled motifs, fan-service callbacks. The quote works because it frames that dynamic as a simple readerly test, then exposes how hard it is to pass. It’s less anti-series than anti-complacency: a warning that repetition, once profitable, starts masquerading as evolution.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List
