"If you're going to use standards as criteria for signing musicians, you can sign thousands. If you're going to use some sort of conceptual interpretation that's based on the tradition of those standards, but is trying to move away from it, you're down to about 10 people or so"
About this Quote
Marsalis is drawing a hard line between competence and voice, and he’s doing it with the blunt practicality of someone who’s sat through a thousand auditions where “good” is cheap. Standards, in jazz, are both repertoire and a test: can you navigate harmony, time, and taste inside a shared language? If that’s the hiring filter, the field is crowded. Plenty of players can nail “All the Things You Are,” sound professional, behave on a bandstand, and deliver the product.
The quote turns when he pivots to “conceptual interpretation.” That phrase is doing a lot of work. He’s talking about musicians who don’t just perform tradition but argue with it - who treat standards as raw material, not a museum piece. The subtext is a critique of an industry that often confuses polish with originality: labels and presenters love measurable benchmarks (intonation, chops, stylistic fluency) because they’re easy to justify. Marsalis is saying the real scarcity is imagination disciplined by lineage, not imagination in ignorance of it.
Context matters: coming from Branford Marsalis, a player who’s moved between straight-ahead jazz, classical collaborations, and pop-adjacent spaces, this isn’t gatekeeping for its own sake. It’s a warning about how “innovation” can become either marketing gloss or disrespectful erasure. His “about 10 people” is obviously rhetorical, but the message is clear: once you demand a personal concept that still speaks the tradition’s grammar, the talent pool collapses. And that’s exactly why those few artists matter.
The quote turns when he pivots to “conceptual interpretation.” That phrase is doing a lot of work. He’s talking about musicians who don’t just perform tradition but argue with it - who treat standards as raw material, not a museum piece. The subtext is a critique of an industry that often confuses polish with originality: labels and presenters love measurable benchmarks (intonation, chops, stylistic fluency) because they’re easy to justify. Marsalis is saying the real scarcity is imagination disciplined by lineage, not imagination in ignorance of it.
Context matters: coming from Branford Marsalis, a player who’s moved between straight-ahead jazz, classical collaborations, and pop-adjacent spaces, this isn’t gatekeeping for its own sake. It’s a warning about how “innovation” can become either marketing gloss or disrespectful erasure. His “about 10 people” is obviously rhetorical, but the message is clear: once you demand a personal concept that still speaks the tradition’s grammar, the talent pool collapses. And that’s exactly why those few artists matter.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Branford
Add to List
