"I'm a born and bred New Yorker. I belong here. Everytime I leave it's like losing a leg"
About this Quote
New York here isn’t a backdrop; it’s a prosthetic you don’t notice until it’s gone. Judy Holliday’s line takes the familiar “city as identity” trope and makes it bodily, even violent: leaving isn’t wistful homesickness, it’s amputation. That escalation is the point. It signals a personality built on speed, crowd-noise, and the constant friction of being watched and having to watch back. For an actress whose comic brilliance depended on timing, tempo, and a certain streetwise innocence, New York reads less like hometown pride than the engine that keeps her calibrated.
The phrasing “born and bred” carries a class-coded edge, too. It’s a preemptive claim of authenticity in a city that’s always been accused of being overrun by strivers and transplants. “I belong here” is doing more than declaring affection; it’s staking jurisdiction. In mid-century American culture, when Hollywood was selling glossy universality from the West Coast, Holliday is insisting on a local frequency: sharper, messier, more alive. You can hear a little defiance under the devotion, as if she’s answering an unasked question about why she didn’t (or couldn’t) fully decamp to the industry’s promised land.
The missing leg metaphor also hints at dependence, even vulnerability. Holliday isn’t romanticizing New York as a postcard; she’s admitting she’s tethered to it. It’s a love story with a power imbalance, and that’s why it lands: the city isn’t just where she’s from, it’s what lets her walk.
The phrasing “born and bred” carries a class-coded edge, too. It’s a preemptive claim of authenticity in a city that’s always been accused of being overrun by strivers and transplants. “I belong here” is doing more than declaring affection; it’s staking jurisdiction. In mid-century American culture, when Hollywood was selling glossy universality from the West Coast, Holliday is insisting on a local frequency: sharper, messier, more alive. You can hear a little defiance under the devotion, as if she’s answering an unasked question about why she didn’t (or couldn’t) fully decamp to the industry’s promised land.
The missing leg metaphor also hints at dependence, even vulnerability. Holliday isn’t romanticizing New York as a postcard; she’s admitting she’s tethered to it. It’s a love story with a power imbalance, and that’s why it lands: the city isn’t just where she’s from, it’s what lets her walk.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nostalgia |
|---|
More Quotes by Judy
Add to List



