"I'm a romantic; a sentimental person thinks things will last, a romantic person hopes against hope that they won't"
About this Quote
Fitzgerald flips the usual Hallmark math of romance and exposes the darker circuitry underneath. In his formulation, “sentimental” is the soft lie: a person who needs permanence to validate feeling, who treats endurance as proof. The “romantic,” by contrast, is almost predatory in his honesty - invested in intensity, not stability, hoping the spell breaks before reality can cheapen it. It’s an inversion that feels like a magician showing you the trapdoor: romance isn’t the belief in forever, it’s the refusal to let “forever” touch the thing and ruin it.
The phrasing does the heavy lifting. “Hopes against hope” is self-incriminating; it admits the desire is irrational, even self-sabotaging, and still pursued with devotion. Fitzgerald makes romanticism sound like an addiction to the unrepeatable, a preference for the clean arc of a tragedy over the slow compromises of a long haul. That edge is classic Fitzgerald: the glamour of longing paired with the suspicion that possessing anything turns it banal.
Context matters. Writing in a culture drunk on reinvention - Jazz Age money, speed, spectacle - Fitzgerald watched desire get monetized and marriages get put under showroom lights. His own life with Zelda was a laboratory for love as performance and pressure. The quote isn’t just a quip; it’s a defense mechanism dressed as philosophy. If the romantic hopes it won’t last, he controls the ending in advance, keeping the beautiful thing safely out of reach, where it can’t be disproven by time.
The phrasing does the heavy lifting. “Hopes against hope” is self-incriminating; it admits the desire is irrational, even self-sabotaging, and still pursued with devotion. Fitzgerald makes romanticism sound like an addiction to the unrepeatable, a preference for the clean arc of a tragedy over the slow compromises of a long haul. That edge is classic Fitzgerald: the glamour of longing paired with the suspicion that possessing anything turns it banal.
Context matters. Writing in a culture drunk on reinvention - Jazz Age money, speed, spectacle - Fitzgerald watched desire get monetized and marriages get put under showroom lights. His own life with Zelda was a laboratory for love as performance and pressure. The quote isn’t just a quip; it’s a defense mechanism dressed as philosophy. If the romantic hopes it won’t last, he controls the ending in advance, keeping the beautiful thing safely out of reach, where it can’t be disproven by time.
Quote Details
| Topic | Romantic |
|---|
More Quotes by Scott Fitzgerald
Add to List
