"I'm a Utilitarian, so I don't see the rule against lying as absolute; it's always subject to some overriding utility which may prevent its exercise"
About this Quote
The phrase “not absolute” does the heavy lifting. It punctures the comfort of moral rules as identity markers (“I’m an honest person”) and drags them into consequence-land, where outcomes judge intentions. Then comes the chillingly bureaucratic turn: “overriding utility” and “prevent its exercise.” He’s describing lying like a switch you flip off when the numbers demand it. That’s the subtext that unsettles: utilitarianism can sound like compassion rendered in spreadsheets.
Context matters because Singer’s career is basically a sustained argument that sentimental taboos should yield to measurable suffering: famine relief, animal ethics, bioethics. This line belongs to that larger project of moral triage. It’s also a tell about his rhetorical strategy: he’s not asking permission to break a rule; he’s questioning why we treat rules as morally self-justifying when what we actually care about is harm. The quote works because it forces a trade: keep moral purity, or take responsibility for consequences.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: Critical Thinking Unleashed (Elliot D. Cohen, 2009)ISBN: 9781442200050 · ID: EXwdvQgObVIC
Evidence:
... Peter Singer advances this argu- ment: I'm a Utilitarian, so I don't see the rule against lying as absolute; it's always subject to some overriding utility which may prevent its exercise. Notice Singer's use of the word “so” to indicate ... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Singer, Peter. (2026, March 25). I'm a Utilitarian, so I don't see the rule against lying as absolute; it's always subject to some overriding utility which may prevent its exercise. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/im-a-utilitarian-so-i-dont-see-the-rule-against-101590/
Chicago Style
Singer, Peter. "I'm a Utilitarian, so I don't see the rule against lying as absolute; it's always subject to some overriding utility which may prevent its exercise." FixQuotes. March 25, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/im-a-utilitarian-so-i-dont-see-the-rule-against-101590/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"I'm a Utilitarian, so I don't see the rule against lying as absolute; it's always subject to some overriding utility which may prevent its exercise." FixQuotes, 25 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/im-a-utilitarian-so-i-dont-see-the-rule-against-101590/. Accessed 31 Mar. 2026.













