"I'm a writer first and a woman after"
About this Quote
A small act of sabotage hides inside Mansfield's clean, declarative order: writer first, woman after. In one breath she refuses the early 20th-century demand that a female author be legible primarily as a woman with opinions, a woman with “sensibility,” a woman writing “women’s books.” The line doesn’t deny gender; it demotes it, insisting that craft outranks category. That’s the provocation. Mansfield is not arguing that womanhood is irrelevant. She’s arguing that readers, editors, and critics keep trying to make it the plot.
The subtext is defensive and strategic. “After” is doing the heavy lifting: it hints at the exhausting performance expected of women in public life, where even talent is treated as an accessory to identity. Mansfield, a modernist moving through London’s literary circuits and their gatekeepers, knew how quickly a woman writer could be domesticated by praise that was really containment. Claiming “writer” as the primary identity is a bid for the same default universality granted to male peers: let the sentences be the evidence, not the body.
Context sharpens the edge. Mansfield’s career unfolded amid suffrage battles, tightening moral codes, and a marketplace eager to sort art by respectable roles. Her own work cuts against those boxes: psychologically precise, formally adventurous, unsentimental about marriage and class. So the line reads less like self-erasure than a demand for professional seriousness. It’s a refusal to be turned into a “case” when she’s trying to be read as a creator.
The subtext is defensive and strategic. “After” is doing the heavy lifting: it hints at the exhausting performance expected of women in public life, where even talent is treated as an accessory to identity. Mansfield, a modernist moving through London’s literary circuits and their gatekeepers, knew how quickly a woman writer could be domesticated by praise that was really containment. Claiming “writer” as the primary identity is a bid for the same default universality granted to male peers: let the sentences be the evidence, not the body.
Context sharpens the edge. Mansfield’s career unfolded amid suffrage battles, tightening moral codes, and a marketplace eager to sort art by respectable roles. Her own work cuts against those boxes: psychologically precise, formally adventurous, unsentimental about marriage and class. So the line reads less like self-erasure than a demand for professional seriousness. It’s a refusal to be turned into a “case” when she’s trying to be read as a creator.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Katherine
Add to List





