"I'm all in favour of free expression provided it's kept rigidly under control"
About this Quote
Bennett’s line lands because it mimics the soothing cadence of liberal tolerance while smuggling in the authoritarian impulse that so often rides shotgun. “All in favour” is the voice of the committee room, the public-service announcement, the well-meaning Brit who prides himself on reasonableness. Then comes the trapdoor: “provided it’s kept rigidly under control.” The phrasing is politely bureaucratic, but the logic is pure domination. Freedom is granted only on the condition that it not behave like freedom.
The intent is comic, but the comedy is diagnostic. Bennett isn’t merely dunking on censorious officials; he’s pointing at the cultural habit of applauding openness in principle while engineering consequences that make genuine openness impossible. The adverb “rigidly” does heavy lifting: it exposes the anxious temperament behind respectable calls for “standards,” “balance,” or “responsibility.” Those words can be sincere, yet they’re also convenient levers for institutions that want the prestige of tolerance without the mess of dissent.
As a dramatist steeped in English social life, Bennett understands how control often arrives wearing good manners. The subtext is that censorship rarely announces itself as censorship. It arrives as procedure, taste, safeguarding, a quiet insistence that everyone may speak as long as they don’t disrupt the room. In a media climate where “free speech” is alternately weaponized and sanitized, the line still bites: it captures the paradox of societies that celebrate expression most loudly when they’ve already decided its acceptable limits.
The intent is comic, but the comedy is diagnostic. Bennett isn’t merely dunking on censorious officials; he’s pointing at the cultural habit of applauding openness in principle while engineering consequences that make genuine openness impossible. The adverb “rigidly” does heavy lifting: it exposes the anxious temperament behind respectable calls for “standards,” “balance,” or “responsibility.” Those words can be sincere, yet they’re also convenient levers for institutions that want the prestige of tolerance without the mess of dissent.
As a dramatist steeped in English social life, Bennett understands how control often arrives wearing good manners. The subtext is that censorship rarely announces itself as censorship. It arrives as procedure, taste, safeguarding, a quiet insistence that everyone may speak as long as they don’t disrupt the room. In a media climate where “free speech” is alternately weaponized and sanitized, the line still bites: it captures the paradox of societies that celebrate expression most loudly when they’ve already decided its acceptable limits.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Alan
Add to List






