"I'm always amazed by writers who tell me they plan everything at the beginning. I feel their writing days must be very bland"
About this Quote
There is a sly provocation in Rose Tremain's amazement: she frames the ultra-planner not just as different, but as someone missing the best part of the job. The jab lands because it uses the language of temperament rather than technique. "Plan everything" isn't criticized as wrong; it's implied to be dull. "Bland" is doing heavy lifting here, smuggling in an aesthetic argument (surprise matters) under the guise of an emotional reaction (she can't imagine living that way).
The subtext is a defense of discovery writing as a creative ethic. Tremain isn't merely describing her process; she's staking out a worldview in which the novel is not executed but encountered. If you already know what happens, the daily work becomes clerical: filling in predetermined boxes. Her tone suggests that suspense should be present not only for the reader but for the writer, too. That shared uncertainty is part of what gives fiction its pulse.
Contextually, this sits inside a long-running craft debate: architects versus gardeners, outliners versus improvisers. Tremain's line has the compact confidence of someone who has earned her preferences on the page. It's also a quiet rebuttal to the productivity culture that treats writing like project management. Planning can be a form of control; Tremain implies that surrendering some control is where the living, volatile material shows up - the character who refuses to behave, the scene that tilts the whole book into a better truth. Calling planned days "bland" isn't just shade. It's a warning about mistaking efficiency for art.
The subtext is a defense of discovery writing as a creative ethic. Tremain isn't merely describing her process; she's staking out a worldview in which the novel is not executed but encountered. If you already know what happens, the daily work becomes clerical: filling in predetermined boxes. Her tone suggests that suspense should be present not only for the reader but for the writer, too. That shared uncertainty is part of what gives fiction its pulse.
Contextually, this sits inside a long-running craft debate: architects versus gardeners, outliners versus improvisers. Tremain's line has the compact confidence of someone who has earned her preferences on the page. It's also a quiet rebuttal to the productivity culture that treats writing like project management. Planning can be a form of control; Tremain implies that surrendering some control is where the living, volatile material shows up - the character who refuses to behave, the scene that tilts the whole book into a better truth. Calling planned days "bland" isn't just shade. It's a warning about mistaking efficiency for art.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Rose
Add to List
