"I'm not a very good writer, but I'm an excellent rewriter"
About this Quote
Michener’s line flatters and deflates the literary ego in the same breath. Coming from a novelist famous for sprawling, research-heavy epics, it’s a quiet refusal of the romantic myth that books arrive in a lightning strike of inspiration. He frames “writer” as the glamorous identity and “rewriter” as the unsexy labor, then admits the second is where the real craft lives. The humility is strategic: it lowers the stakes of the first draft, making creation feel less like a test of talent and more like a process you can return to, tool in hand.
The subtext is a rebuke to the cult of genius. By calling himself “not very good,” Michener isn’t confessing incompetence; he’s redefining what “good” means. In his world, the initial pages are raw material. The excellence is in revision: cutting the self-indulgent paragraph, repairing logic, tightening scenes, verifying facts, sharpening cadence. “Rewriter” implies discipline, patience, and a willingness to be wrong on purpose the first time.
Context matters because Michener built novels the way an architect builds cities: outlines, interviews, historical scaffolding, drafts upon drafts. For a working novelist, revision isn’t cosmetic; it’s where voice becomes intelligible and where research turns into narrative. The line also reads like permission slipped under the door to anxious writers: you don’t need to be brilliant at birth; you need to be brave enough to rewrite until the work tells the truth.
The subtext is a rebuke to the cult of genius. By calling himself “not very good,” Michener isn’t confessing incompetence; he’s redefining what “good” means. In his world, the initial pages are raw material. The excellence is in revision: cutting the self-indulgent paragraph, repairing logic, tightening scenes, verifying facts, sharpening cadence. “Rewriter” implies discipline, patience, and a willingness to be wrong on purpose the first time.
Context matters because Michener built novels the way an architect builds cities: outlines, interviews, historical scaffolding, drafts upon drafts. For a working novelist, revision isn’t cosmetic; it’s where voice becomes intelligible and where research turns into narrative. The line also reads like permission slipped under the door to anxious writers: you don’t need to be brilliant at birth; you need to be brave enough to rewrite until the work tells the truth.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Quote attributed to James A. Michener: "I'm not a very good writer, but I'm an excellent rewriter." — cited on Wikiquote (no primary source given on that page). |
More Quotes by James
Add to List



