"I'm not an historian and I'm not wanting to write about how I perceive the social change over the century as a historian, but as somebody who's walked through it and whose life has been dictated by it too, as all our lives are"
About this Quote
Penelope Lively is dodging the podium while quietly claiming the microphone. By insisting she is "not an historian", she rejects the godlike, archive-driven authority we often demand from anyone speaking about "social change". But the sentence immediately turns into a counterclaim: she has "walked through it". Lively positions lived experience as a rival form of evidence, not tidy or comprehensive, but intimate, compromised, and therefore honest. It is a writer's move: skeptical of grand narratives, alert to how memory edits reality, yet unwilling to pretend that change is best understood only from a distance.
The repetition of "not" and the careful qualifications ("I'm not wanting to write... as a historian") reveal a deeper anxiety about genre and permission. Who gets to narrate a century? Lively refuses the historian's pose of neutrality, then admits why neutrality is impossible anyway: her "life has been dictated by it". That verb, dictated, is doing heavy lifting. Social change isn't a backdrop; it's a script that assigns roles, opens doors, closes them, and makes certain selves legible or obsolete. Even those who imagine they stand outside history are, in her blunt aside, living proof of its pressure: "as all our lives are."
Context matters here: a woman born in 1933, writing in a Britain remade by war, welfare state, feminism, decolonization, and neoliberal turn. Lively's intent is to offer not a timeline but a felt record of forces that shape ordinary choices, and to remind us that personal narrative isn't a retreat from history; it's where history lands.
The repetition of "not" and the careful qualifications ("I'm not wanting to write... as a historian") reveal a deeper anxiety about genre and permission. Who gets to narrate a century? Lively refuses the historian's pose of neutrality, then admits why neutrality is impossible anyway: her "life has been dictated by it". That verb, dictated, is doing heavy lifting. Social change isn't a backdrop; it's a script that assigns roles, opens doors, closes them, and makes certain selves legible or obsolete. Even those who imagine they stand outside history are, in her blunt aside, living proof of its pressure: "as all our lives are."
Context matters here: a woman born in 1933, writing in a Britain remade by war, welfare state, feminism, decolonization, and neoliberal turn. Lively's intent is to offer not a timeline but a felt record of forces that shape ordinary choices, and to remind us that personal narrative isn't a retreat from history; it's where history lands.
Quote Details
| Topic | Change |
|---|
More Quotes by Penelope
Add to List
