"I'm not as hopeful as I was when I was young"
About this Quote
Hope is supposed to age like wine; Irwin Shaw lets it age like newsprint. "I'm not as hopeful as I was when I was young" is blunt enough to sound like a confession, but it’s engineered as a verdict: time doesn’t just add experience, it edits your expectations. Shaw isn’t performing the romantic posture of the disillusioned artist; he’s registering a moral ledger, the cumulative arithmetic of witnessing how people and institutions actually behave when the stakes are real.
The line works because it refuses drama. No grand talk of betrayal or shattered dreams, just a quiet comparative: not as hopeful. That understatement is the sting. It implies hope was once abundant, maybe even default, and that its reduction is rational - earned, not chosen. The subtext is generational: youth lends you the luxury of believing history bends toward decency because you haven’t watched it snap back.
Context matters with Shaw. Born in 1913, he matured through Depression austerity, World War II, the Holocaust’s shadow, and the Cold War’s paranoia. In the U.S., McCarthyism turned ideology into a loyalty test; Shaw was blacklisted, a lived lesson in how quickly a society can punish dissent while insisting it’s defending freedom. That history sits behind the sentence like a low hum.
Intent-wise, Shaw isn’t asking for sympathy; he’s warning against naive optimism as a civic strategy. The most unsettling implication: losing hope isn’t the tragedy. The tragedy is realizing how reasonable it is.
The line works because it refuses drama. No grand talk of betrayal or shattered dreams, just a quiet comparative: not as hopeful. That understatement is the sting. It implies hope was once abundant, maybe even default, and that its reduction is rational - earned, not chosen. The subtext is generational: youth lends you the luxury of believing history bends toward decency because you haven’t watched it snap back.
Context matters with Shaw. Born in 1913, he matured through Depression austerity, World War II, the Holocaust’s shadow, and the Cold War’s paranoia. In the U.S., McCarthyism turned ideology into a loyalty test; Shaw was blacklisted, a lived lesson in how quickly a society can punish dissent while insisting it’s defending freedom. That history sits behind the sentence like a low hum.
Intent-wise, Shaw isn’t asking for sympathy; he’s warning against naive optimism as a civic strategy. The most unsettling implication: losing hope isn’t the tragedy. The tragedy is realizing how reasonable it is.
Quote Details
| Topic | Aging |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Irwin
Add to List






