"I'm not really a Jew; just Jew-ish, not the whole hog"
About this Quote
The joke does two jobs at once. It deflates the policing of authenticity (who counts, who doesn’t) while quietly admitting the pressure behind that policing. “Not the whole hog” borrows the language of appetite and indulgence, suggesting that “real” belonging is imagined as total consumption: you either take the full portion of ritual, belief, community obligation, history, and vulnerability, or you’re nibbling at the edges. Miller positions himself as a partial participant, but the line’s briskness also protects him: humor as a preemptive strike against judgment, including his own.
Context matters because Miller came of age in postwar Britain, where Jewish identity was simultaneously visible, fraught, and negotiable in elite cultural spaces. Assimilation offered access; it also demanded a certain lightness about difference. The quip sounds casual, but it’s engineered: a way to acknowledge inherited identity without letting it become a single, defining script. In one breath, he claims lineage, rejects caricature, and refuses anyone else the authority to grade his Jewishness.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Unverified source: The New Yorker: Doctor in Spite of Himself (Jonathan Miller, 1989)
Evidence: “I’m not a Jew,” he stated conspiratorially to the audience of the celebrated revue called “Beyond the Fringe” when it burst on the Edinburgh Festival in 1960. “No, I’m not a Jew. I’m Jew-ish. I don’t go the whole hog.” (Print issue dated April 17, 1989 (page number not accessible from the free w... Other candidates (1) The Mammoth Book of Comic Quotes (Geoff Tibballs, 2012) compilation90.9% ... I'm not really a Jew ; just Jew - ish , not the whole hog . MAUREEN LIPMAN WALTER MATTHAU JONATHAN MILLER , Beyon... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Miller, Jonathan. (2026, February 18). I'm not really a Jew; just Jew-ish, not the whole hog. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/im-not-really-a-jew-just-jew-ish-not-the-whole-hog-129683/
Chicago Style
Miller, Jonathan. "I'm not really a Jew; just Jew-ish, not the whole hog." FixQuotes. February 18, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/im-not-really-a-jew-just-jew-ish-not-the-whole-hog-129683/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"I'm not really a Jew; just Jew-ish, not the whole hog." FixQuotes, 18 Feb. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/im-not-really-a-jew-just-jew-ish-not-the-whole-hog-129683/. Accessed 24 Feb. 2026.





