"Immigration should be enforced in a proportional and humane manner"
About this Quote
“Proportional and humane” is careful clergy language that smuggles a moral indictment into the blandest possible policy phrasing. Mahony isn’t drafting legislation; he’s staking a claim about what kind of country enforcement reveals. “Enforced” concedes the state’s right to regulate borders, a nod to skeptics who equate compassion with chaos. The modifier “proportional” then tightens the screws: punishment should match harm, and being undocumented is not the same as being dangerous. It’s a quiet rebuke to the post-9/11 habit of treating immigration as a security theater problem, where raids, detention, and family separation become default tools rather than last resorts.
The subtext is pastoral and political at once. As a Catholic leader, Mahony is pulling from a tradition that centers human dignity, the primacy of family, and the moral test of how societies treat the vulnerable. “Humane” isn’t just “be nice”; it implies that cruelty is already on the table, normalized through bureaucratic language and routine procedure. In that sense, the line functions like a conscience-check aimed at policymakers who want the optics of order without owning the costs.
Context matters: Mahony became a prominent voice during the heated U.S. immigration battles of the 2000s, when proposals ramped up criminal penalties and expanded enforcement powers. This sentence is built to travel across TV panels and pulpit sermons alike: short, nontechnical, hard to argue against without sounding pro-brutality. That’s the point. It forces opponents to either accept the moral frame or publicly reject it.
The subtext is pastoral and political at once. As a Catholic leader, Mahony is pulling from a tradition that centers human dignity, the primacy of family, and the moral test of how societies treat the vulnerable. “Humane” isn’t just “be nice”; it implies that cruelty is already on the table, normalized through bureaucratic language and routine procedure. In that sense, the line functions like a conscience-check aimed at policymakers who want the optics of order without owning the costs.
Context matters: Mahony became a prominent voice during the heated U.S. immigration battles of the 2000s, when proposals ramped up criminal penalties and expanded enforcement powers. This sentence is built to travel across TV panels and pulpit sermons alike: short, nontechnical, hard to argue against without sounding pro-brutality. That’s the point. It forces opponents to either accept the moral frame or publicly reject it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Roger
Add to List
