"Imprisoning convicted criminals for longer and longer periods sounds like an appealing and commonsense proposal to many people. After all, when lawbreakers are locked up they can't commit more crimes and law-abiding citizens are safer. Right? Actually, wrong"
About this Quote
The intent isn’t merely to critique incarceration; it’s to challenge an audience’s reliance on a single, linear model of public safety: remove the “bad people,” reduce harm. By calling it “commonsense,” he subtly downgrades the belief as pre-analytical, a folk theory. The subtext: our current approach may feel satisfying, even moral, but it’s strategically lazy and likely counterproductive. That implies a second claim hovering just offstage: crime is shaped by incentives, reentry, community stability, and deterrence dynamics that long sentences can worsen.
Context matters. This is a message designed for an era where “tough on crime” still polls well, yet mass incarceration’s costs are harder to ignore. Kirk’s rhetorical move is to grant the fear, then redirect it: not toward empathy, but toward efficiency. Safety remains the metric; the method gets put on trial.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: Fox News: The First Step Act prison reform bill deserves ... (Charlie Kirk, 2018)
Evidence:
Imprisoning convicted criminals for longer and longer periods sounds like an appealing and commonsense proposal to many people. After all, when lawbreakers are locked up they can’t commit more crimes and law-abiding citizens are safer. Right? Actually, wrong.. This wording appears verbatim at the start of Charlie Kirk’s Fox News Opinion piece. The article is timestamped/published December 6, 2018 (12:07pm EST) and is a primary source (Kirk’s own byline). I did not find an earlier primary-source publication in the time available; many quote-aggregation sites appear to have copied it from this column. |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Kirk, Charlie. (2026, February 9). Imprisoning convicted criminals for longer and longer periods sounds like an appealing and commonsense proposal to many people. After all, when lawbreakers are locked up they can't commit more crimes and law-abiding citizens are safer. Right? Actually, wrong. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/imprisoning-convicted-criminals-for-longer-and-173255/
Chicago Style
Kirk, Charlie. "Imprisoning convicted criminals for longer and longer periods sounds like an appealing and commonsense proposal to many people. After all, when lawbreakers are locked up they can't commit more crimes and law-abiding citizens are safer. Right? Actually, wrong." FixQuotes. February 9, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/imprisoning-convicted-criminals-for-longer-and-173255/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Imprisoning convicted criminals for longer and longer periods sounds like an appealing and commonsense proposal to many people. After all, when lawbreakers are locked up they can't commit more crimes and law-abiding citizens are safer. Right? Actually, wrong." FixQuotes, 9 Feb. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/imprisoning-convicted-criminals-for-longer-and-173255/. Accessed 12 Feb. 2026.






