"In a good play every speech should be as fully flavored as a nut or apple"
About this Quote
Synge’s line lands like a small rebuke to the watery, “serviceable” dialogue that clogs bad theater. “Fully flavored” isn’t a vague compliment; it’s a sensory demand. A nut or apple is compact, ordinary, and unmistakably itself. You don’t need a lecture to know when it’s fresh, when it’s stale, when it’s been overhandled. Synge is arguing that stage speech should work the same way: not ornamental speeches draped over action, but language with bite, texture, and a traceable origin in lived experience.
The subtext is a manifesto against pallid literary prettiness. Synge came out of the Irish Literary Revival, where the fight wasn’t just for Irish stories but for an Irish idiom that sounded like people, not like imported drawing-room drama. “Every speech” is the key pressure point: he’s not talking about one big monologue that wins awards; he’s talking about the relentless craft of making each line carry its own nourishment. Flavor implies density, specificity, and risk: local turns of phrase, humor that cuts, rhythm that behaves like music, not exposition.
There’s also a quiet ethical claim embedded in the metaphor. An apple is honest. It can’t fake ripeness for long. Synge is telling playwrights that the audience will taste the shortcuts: lines that exist only to move plot, speeches that advertise themes, dialogue that performs “importance” instead of revealing character. In his work, speech isn’t decoration; it’s the dramatic engine, the place where class, desire, pride, and cruelty show up uninvited.
The subtext is a manifesto against pallid literary prettiness. Synge came out of the Irish Literary Revival, where the fight wasn’t just for Irish stories but for an Irish idiom that sounded like people, not like imported drawing-room drama. “Every speech” is the key pressure point: he’s not talking about one big monologue that wins awards; he’s talking about the relentless craft of making each line carry its own nourishment. Flavor implies density, specificity, and risk: local turns of phrase, humor that cuts, rhythm that behaves like music, not exposition.
There’s also a quiet ethical claim embedded in the metaphor. An apple is honest. It can’t fake ripeness for long. Synge is telling playwrights that the audience will taste the shortcuts: lines that exist only to move plot, speeches that advertise themes, dialogue that performs “importance” instead of revealing character. In his work, speech isn’t decoration; it’s the dramatic engine, the place where class, desire, pride, and cruelty show up uninvited.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
