"In a state therefore of great equality and virtue, where pure and simple manners prevailed, the increase of the human species would evidently be much greater than any increase that has been hitherto known"
About this Quote
Malthus sells a paradox in the velvet language of moral praise: the more equal and virtuous a society becomes, the faster it will multiply itself into trouble. The sentence is staged like a compliment to “pure and simple manners,” but the payload is diagnostic and faintly menacing. Equality, in his framing, is not just a political ideal; it’s a demographic accelerant. Strip away vice, insecurity, and aristocratic constraint, and you remove the brakes on birth rates. The result is “evidently” larger families, as if nature itself were waiting to rush in the moment humans get their ethics together.
The intent here is polemical. Malthus is arguing against the late-18th-century optimism of reformers who believed better institutions would produce stable abundance and harmony. His move is to smuggle a counterclaim into the rhetoric of virtue: even the best-run society contains the seeds of pressure, because reproduction responds faster than food production. The subtext is a warning to utopians: your moral progress doesn’t repeal arithmetic.
Context matters. Writing in the shadow of the French Revolution and amidst early industrial upheaval, Malthus is both resisting revolutionary dreams and offering a new kind of authority: social theory that sounds like natural law. Notice how the sentence avoids cruelty by outsourcing it to inevitability. If hardship follows equality, it’s not because elites hoard; it’s because bodies reproduce. That quiet pivot sets up the rest of the Malthusian project: shifting debates about poverty from politics and distribution to discipline, restraint, and the “limits” of sympathy.
The intent here is polemical. Malthus is arguing against the late-18th-century optimism of reformers who believed better institutions would produce stable abundance and harmony. His move is to smuggle a counterclaim into the rhetoric of virtue: even the best-run society contains the seeds of pressure, because reproduction responds faster than food production. The subtext is a warning to utopians: your moral progress doesn’t repeal arithmetic.
Context matters. Writing in the shadow of the French Revolution and amidst early industrial upheaval, Malthus is both resisting revolutionary dreams and offering a new kind of authority: social theory that sounds like natural law. Notice how the sentence avoids cruelty by outsourcing it to inevitability. If hardship follows equality, it’s not because elites hoard; it’s because bodies reproduce. That quiet pivot sets up the rest of the Malthusian project: shifting debates about poverty from politics and distribution to discipline, restraint, and the “limits” of sympathy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List





