"In all secrets there is a kind of guilt, however beautiful or joyful they may be, or for what good end they may be set to serve. Secrecy means evasion, and evasion means a problem to the moral mind"
About this Quote
Secrecy is framed here less as a practical tool than as a moral contaminant: the moment you hide something, Parker argues, you’ve already conceded a breach with your own conscience. The line is built like a legal brief. He grants the best-case defenses up front - the secret might be beautiful, joyful, even in service of a “good end” - then revokes their exculpatory power. That rhetorical move matters. It doesn’t deny complexity; it refuses to let complexity become a loophole.
As a politician, Parker is writing from inside the machinery that runs on controlled information. That makes the statement feel like both confession and warning. The subtext is that secrecy isn’t neutral statecraft; it’s self-protection, coalition-management, reputational triage. “Evasion” is the key word: not merely concealment, but a dodge, a sidestep of accountability. Once you evade, the “moral mind” can’t rest, because it knows it’s managing appearances rather than facing truth.
The sentence also smuggles in a democratic ethic without naming it. If secrecy equals evasion, then public life built on secrecy quietly corrodes civic trust; even well-intended concealment teaches leaders to treat citizens as obstacles to be navigated rather than partners to be persuaded. Parker’s insistence on “guilt” isn’t puritanical so much as psychological: secrets create an internal double-bookkeeping that demands constant maintenance. You might get your policy win, your diplomatic breakthrough, your spared feelings - but you pay in moral static.
As a politician, Parker is writing from inside the machinery that runs on controlled information. That makes the statement feel like both confession and warning. The subtext is that secrecy isn’t neutral statecraft; it’s self-protection, coalition-management, reputational triage. “Evasion” is the key word: not merely concealment, but a dodge, a sidestep of accountability. Once you evade, the “moral mind” can’t rest, because it knows it’s managing appearances rather than facing truth.
The sentence also smuggles in a democratic ethic without naming it. If secrecy equals evasion, then public life built on secrecy quietly corrodes civic trust; even well-intended concealment teaches leaders to treat citizens as obstacles to be navigated rather than partners to be persuaded. Parker’s insistence on “guilt” isn’t puritanical so much as psychological: secrets create an internal double-bookkeeping that demands constant maintenance. You might get your policy win, your diplomatic breakthrough, your spared feelings - but you pay in moral static.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Gilbert
Add to List









