"In all sincere speech there is power, not necessarily great power, but as much as the speaker is capable of"
About this Quote
Sincerity isn’t a halo in Lewes’s line; it’s a battery. He’s making a calibrated claim about rhetoric that refuses both cynicism (“all speech is manipulation”) and romanticism (“truth automatically persuades”). Power, for him, is not a moral prize awarded to the honest. It’s a measurable output: whatever voltage the speaker can actually generate when their words and convictions align.
The sly move is in the qualifier: “not necessarily great power.” Lewes, a Victorian philosopher with a strong interest in psychology and the mechanics of mind, strips sincerity of its sentimental overpromise. Honest speech can still be small, awkward, unpolished. The point is that it won’t be hollow. Sincerity concentrates whatever ability is already there; it doesn’t create ability from nothing. That’s a quietly egalitarian idea (anyone can have some power in speech) and a quietly ruthless one (your “some” might be modest, and sincerity won’t save you).
Subtext: Lewes is also taking a side in a long 19th-century argument about authenticity versus performance. The era’s public life was thick with oratory, moralizing, religious testimony, and political persuasion. Against the suspicion that speech is mere technique, he insists that conviction registers at the level of force. But he also anticipates modern skepticism about “authenticity” as branding by tying power to capacity, not purity. The line flatters neither the demagogue nor the saint; it’s a diagnosis. Sincere speech works because coherence between belief and utterance is legible - and because audiences, then as now, can feel the difference between a message that’s lived and one that’s merely deployed.
The sly move is in the qualifier: “not necessarily great power.” Lewes, a Victorian philosopher with a strong interest in psychology and the mechanics of mind, strips sincerity of its sentimental overpromise. Honest speech can still be small, awkward, unpolished. The point is that it won’t be hollow. Sincerity concentrates whatever ability is already there; it doesn’t create ability from nothing. That’s a quietly egalitarian idea (anyone can have some power in speech) and a quietly ruthless one (your “some” might be modest, and sincerity won’t save you).
Subtext: Lewes is also taking a side in a long 19th-century argument about authenticity versus performance. The era’s public life was thick with oratory, moralizing, religious testimony, and political persuasion. Against the suspicion that speech is mere technique, he insists that conviction registers at the level of force. But he also anticipates modern skepticism about “authenticity” as branding by tying power to capacity, not purity. The line flatters neither the demagogue nor the saint; it’s a diagnosis. Sincere speech works because coherence between belief and utterance is legible - and because audiences, then as now, can feel the difference between a message that’s lived and one that’s merely deployed.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List
