"In any case, his judgment and set of values, acting alone or through his assistants, determine not only what is gold and what is dross but the design of the history which he creates out of the metal. The historian decides what is significant, and what is not"
About this Quote
The intent is bracingly professional: a reminder that significance is not discovered, it’s assigned. Morison isn’t merely warning about distortion; he’s arguing that selection is the job. A historian who claims to include “everything” is either lying or producing unreadable sludge. The subtext is more uncomfortable: if significance is assigned, then power follows the assigner. What counts as “gold” tracks the historian’s class position, nationalism, moral priorities, and the era’s common sense. The archive may be vast, but the narrative is a designed object.
Context matters with Morison. As a celebrated American historian writing in a century of nation-building histories (and as someone often criticized for a patrician, Eurocentric frame), he’s also half-confessing. He knows that histories don’t just report the past; they manufacture civic memory. His phrasing makes that manufacturing sound almost artisanal - “design” suggests craft, even elegance - while quietly admitting the ethical hazard: once you decide what’s “significant,” you decide who gets to be real.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Morison, Samuel E. (2026, January 16). In any case, his judgment and set of values, acting alone or through his assistants, determine not only what is gold and what is dross but the design of the history which he creates out of the metal. The historian decides what is significant, and what is not. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/in-any-case-his-judgment-and-set-of-values-acting-130688/
Chicago Style
Morison, Samuel E. "In any case, his judgment and set of values, acting alone or through his assistants, determine not only what is gold and what is dross but the design of the history which he creates out of the metal. The historian decides what is significant, and what is not." FixQuotes. January 16, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/in-any-case-his-judgment-and-set-of-values-acting-130688/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"In any case, his judgment and set of values, acting alone or through his assistants, determine not only what is gold and what is dross but the design of the history which he creates out of the metal. The historian decides what is significant, and what is not." FixQuotes, 16 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/in-any-case-his-judgment-and-set-of-values-acting-130688/. Accessed 12 Feb. 2026.












