"In any really good subject, one has only to probe deep enough to come to tears"
About this Quote
Wharton’s line is a dagger aimed at the genteel illusion that “good” subjects are refined, safe, and discussable at dinner. She argues the opposite: if a subject is genuinely worth attention, it eventually stops being an object you handle and becomes a force that handles you. “Probe” matters here. It’s not passive appreciation; it’s excavation, a deliberate refusal to skim. Depth isn’t rewarded with trivia or cleverness but with tears - the body’s most involuntary verdict that you’ve reached something true.
The subtext is almost a manifesto against the ornamental intelligence Wharton knew intimately: the cultivated talk, the polished tastes, the social codes designed to keep feeling at arm’s length. Her fiction anatomizes those surfaces in Old New York drawing rooms, where the real drama is what can’t be admitted. So the line reads as both aesthetic claim and moral warning. If you stay on the surface, you can remain witty, correct, untouched. Go deep enough and you meet what the surface was built to hide: grief, longing, shame, the cost of choices, the quiet violence of convention.
Contextually, this is Wharton’s broader project: to show that “civilization” doesn’t eliminate pain; it choreographs it. Tears aren’t sentimental payoff. They’re evidence that the subject has connective tissue to human stakes. A “really good subject” isn’t one that flatters the mind; it’s one that breaks the mind’s defenses.
The subtext is almost a manifesto against the ornamental intelligence Wharton knew intimately: the cultivated talk, the polished tastes, the social codes designed to keep feeling at arm’s length. Her fiction anatomizes those surfaces in Old New York drawing rooms, where the real drama is what can’t be admitted. So the line reads as both aesthetic claim and moral warning. If you stay on the surface, you can remain witty, correct, untouched. Go deep enough and you meet what the surface was built to hide: grief, longing, shame, the cost of choices, the quiet violence of convention.
Contextually, this is Wharton’s broader project: to show that “civilization” doesn’t eliminate pain; it choreographs it. Tears aren’t sentimental payoff. They’re evidence that the subject has connective tissue to human stakes. A “really good subject” isn’t one that flatters the mind; it’s one that breaks the mind’s defenses.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Edith
Add to List
