"In days when the public safety is imminently threatened, and the fate of a nation may hang upon a single act, we owe frank speech, above all other men, to him who is highest in authority. I shall speak to you as man to man"
About this Quote
Crisis is Owen's permission slip for candor, and it's also a subtle indictment of the culture that normally punishes it. By opening with "public safety" and the melodramatic knife-edge image - "the fate of a nation may hang upon a single act" - he shrinks the space for polite equivocation. If one decision can tip the whole country, then tone-policing becomes a luxury the moment cannot afford. The rhetoric turns urgency into moral leverage.
The key move is who "owes" what to whom. Owen flips the usual hierarchy: deference is not what's demanded of citizens when the stakes are high; honesty is what's demanded of leaders. "We owe frank speech...to him who is highest in authority" sounds respectful, but the subtext is closer to accountability. The leader does not get comfort; he gets truth. It's a canny way to criticize power while appearing to serve it.
"I shall speak to you as man to man" is both egalitarian and strategic. In a political culture thick with ceremony, it strips away office and asks the authority figure to meet on the only ground that matters in emergencies: shared human responsibility. It also preemptively disarms retaliation. If the exchange is personal rather than partisan, then disagreement can't be dismissed as factional sniping.
Contextually, Owen - a reform-minded politician in a young, fractious republic - is working a familiar American seam: reverence for institutions paired with suspicion of the people running them. The line is less about manners than about forcing a decision-maker to hear the unvarnished costs of inaction.
The key move is who "owes" what to whom. Owen flips the usual hierarchy: deference is not what's demanded of citizens when the stakes are high; honesty is what's demanded of leaders. "We owe frank speech...to him who is highest in authority" sounds respectful, but the subtext is closer to accountability. The leader does not get comfort; he gets truth. It's a canny way to criticize power while appearing to serve it.
"I shall speak to you as man to man" is both egalitarian and strategic. In a political culture thick with ceremony, it strips away office and asks the authority figure to meet on the only ground that matters in emergencies: shared human responsibility. It also preemptively disarms retaliation. If the exchange is personal rather than partisan, then disagreement can't be dismissed as factional sniping.
Contextually, Owen - a reform-minded politician in a young, fractious republic - is working a familiar American seam: reverence for institutions paired with suspicion of the people running them. The line is less about manners than about forcing a decision-maker to hear the unvarnished costs of inaction.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
