"In fact, the Harvard study data indicates that 70 percent of African American children attend schools that are predominately African American, about the same level as in 1968 when Dr. King died"
About this Quote
The line lands like a cold receipt: history ran up the bill, and we are still paying it. By anchoring his point to “Harvard study data” and then snapping the timeline back to 1968, Bobby Scott isn’t just reporting a statistic; he’s staging a moral comparison. The move is deliberately prosecutorial. If the numbers are “about the same level” as the year Dr. King died, then the promised arc of progress is revealed as more slogan than substance.
Scott’s specific intent is political leverage. He’s using empirical authority to box in the audience: you can argue ideology, but it’s harder to argue a peer-reviewed percentage. The subtext is sharper: desegregation wasn’t simply “undone,” it was never fully completed, and the country has grown comfortable calling stability “improvement” as long as the language around it sounds gentler.
Invoking King is not sentimental; it’s strategic. 1968 functions as a civic landmark, a moment most Americans recognize as unfinished business. Scott is also quietly indicting policy choices made after the civil-rights era: housing segregation, district boundaries, white flight, uneven school funding, and the legal narrowing of desegregation remedies. “Predominately” does a lot of work, too, offering a veneer of technical neutrality while pointing to a lived reality: students’ educational opportunities are still shaped by race, even when nobody says “separate” out loud.
The rhetoric isn’t about nostalgia for a movement; it’s about exposing how easily a nation can commemorate justice while maintaining its architecture of separation.
Scott’s specific intent is political leverage. He’s using empirical authority to box in the audience: you can argue ideology, but it’s harder to argue a peer-reviewed percentage. The subtext is sharper: desegregation wasn’t simply “undone,” it was never fully completed, and the country has grown comfortable calling stability “improvement” as long as the language around it sounds gentler.
Invoking King is not sentimental; it’s strategic. 1968 functions as a civic landmark, a moment most Americans recognize as unfinished business. Scott is also quietly indicting policy choices made after the civil-rights era: housing segregation, district boundaries, white flight, uneven school funding, and the legal narrowing of desegregation remedies. “Predominately” does a lot of work, too, offering a veneer of technical neutrality while pointing to a lived reality: students’ educational opportunities are still shaped by race, even when nobody says “separate” out loud.
The rhetoric isn’t about nostalgia for a movement; it’s about exposing how easily a nation can commemorate justice while maintaining its architecture of separation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Bobby
Add to List
