"In Georgia where children work day and night in the cotton mills they have just passed a bill to protect song birds. What about the little children from whom all song is gone?"
About this Quote
The line lands like a slap because it weaponizes a feel-good reform against itself. Mary Harris "Mother" Jones juxtaposes two kinds of innocence - songbirds and children - then exposes how legislation can become moral theater: protect the picturesque, ignore the profited-upon. Georgia lawmakers get to look tender-hearted without touching the economic machinery that grinds kids into shift work. The cruelty is not accidental; its invisibility is the point.
Jones' intent is agitational and surgical. She isn't asking for a broader compassion; she's indicting a selective one that serves power. Songbirds are safe to save because they don't unionize, strike, or demand shorter hours. They let elites perform stewardship while leaving industrial discipline intact. Her rhetorical pivot - "What about" - turns a conservation bill into evidence of political cowardice, a public relations bandage over a moral wound.
The subtext is also about voice. "From whom all song is gone" isn't just poetic; it's an accusation that the system steals childhood's basic register: play, rest, even the ability to sound like a child. In the early 1900s, child labor in Southern textile mills was defended as necessary, even character-building, while progressivism often preferred cleaner causes that didn't threaten mill owners. Jones shames that preference. She forces her audience to see that empathy can be curated like a garden - birdsong preserved for the comfortable, silence imposed on the young who make the wealth.
Jones' intent is agitational and surgical. She isn't asking for a broader compassion; she's indicting a selective one that serves power. Songbirds are safe to save because they don't unionize, strike, or demand shorter hours. They let elites perform stewardship while leaving industrial discipline intact. Her rhetorical pivot - "What about" - turns a conservation bill into evidence of political cowardice, a public relations bandage over a moral wound.
The subtext is also about voice. "From whom all song is gone" isn't just poetic; it's an accusation that the system steals childhood's basic register: play, rest, even the ability to sound like a child. In the early 1900s, child labor in Southern textile mills was defended as necessary, even character-building, while progressivism often preferred cleaner causes that didn't threaten mill owners. Jones shames that preference. She forces her audience to see that empathy can be curated like a garden - birdsong preserved for the comfortable, silence imposed on the young who make the wealth.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Mary
Add to List
