"In improvisation, there are no mistakes"
About this Quote
“In improvisation, there are no mistakes” isn’t feel-good permission to play sloppy; it’s Wayne Shorter smuggling a hard rule inside a soft slogan. Coming from a musician who helped redefine modern jazz with Miles Davis and Weather Report, the line lands like a dare: stop treating music as a test you can fail and start treating it as a conversation you’re responsible for steering.
The intent is practical. In improvisation, the “wrong” note only becomes wrong if you abandon it. Shorter’s point is that every sound can be framed, repeated, reharmonized, or answered. What looks like an error is often just an unexpected turn that demands follow-through. He’s arguing for commitment as an aesthetic: you don’t edit yourself mid-sentence; you make the sentence work.
The subtext is psychological, almost moral. Jazz history is full of virtuosity, but Shorter was obsessed with imagination and risk, the willingness to step into the unknown without a safety net. “No mistakes” is how you keep fear from shrinking your options. The enemy isn’t a sour note; it’s the reflex to apologize for it, to retreat to something pre-approved.
Context matters: post-bop and fusion weren’t simply new styles, they were rebellions against fixed templates. Shorter’s music thrives on ambiguity, shifting harmony, open forms. His quote is a manifesto for that world: meaning isn’t discovered by avoiding errors, it’s created by responding, in real time, to whatever just happened.
The intent is practical. In improvisation, the “wrong” note only becomes wrong if you abandon it. Shorter’s point is that every sound can be framed, repeated, reharmonized, or answered. What looks like an error is often just an unexpected turn that demands follow-through. He’s arguing for commitment as an aesthetic: you don’t edit yourself mid-sentence; you make the sentence work.
The subtext is psychological, almost moral. Jazz history is full of virtuosity, but Shorter was obsessed with imagination and risk, the willingness to step into the unknown without a safety net. “No mistakes” is how you keep fear from shrinking your options. The enemy isn’t a sour note; it’s the reflex to apologize for it, to retreat to something pre-approved.
Context matters: post-bop and fusion weren’t simply new styles, they were rebellions against fixed templates. Shorter’s music thrives on ambiguity, shifting harmony, open forms. His quote is a manifesto for that world: meaning isn’t discovered by avoiding errors, it’s created by responding, in real time, to whatever just happened.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Wayne
Add to List




