"In polite society one laughs at all the jokes, including the ones one has heard before"
About this Quote
Politeness, Dane suggests, is less about good manners than about disciplined participation in a shared performance. The line lands because it flatters and indicts at once: you recognize the social reflex of laughing, and you also feel the quiet shame of how automatic it can be. “Polite society” isn’t simply a setting; it’s a system with rules, and laughter functions like a membership badge. You don’t laugh because the joke is new or even funny. You laugh because the moment demands a signal that you’re aligned, easy to be with, not a threat.
The sly twist is “including the ones one has heard before.” That clause exposes the transactional core of the exchange. Repetition becomes the point. The familiar joke is a test: will you prioritize authenticity (your real reaction) or social continuity (everyone else’s comfort)? Dane implies that what’s being protected isn’t humor but harmony, and harmony is often just conflict avoidance in a tuxedo.
There’s also an undercurrent of power. If you’re laughing on cue, someone else gets to set the cue. Polite laughter can be a small form of deference to the teller, the room, the hierarchy. It’s not that the listener is foolish; it’s that they’re literate in the codes. The quote reads like a writer’s note from the edge of a dinner party: amused, slightly weary, and alert to how “society” trains us to trade honest response for smooth surfaces.
The sly twist is “including the ones one has heard before.” That clause exposes the transactional core of the exchange. Repetition becomes the point. The familiar joke is a test: will you prioritize authenticity (your real reaction) or social continuity (everyone else’s comfort)? Dane implies that what’s being protected isn’t humor but harmony, and harmony is often just conflict avoidance in a tuxedo.
There’s also an undercurrent of power. If you’re laughing on cue, someone else gets to set the cue. Polite laughter can be a small form of deference to the teller, the room, the hierarchy. It’s not that the listener is foolish; it’s that they’re literate in the codes. The quote reads like a writer’s note from the edge of a dinner party: amused, slightly weary, and alert to how “society” trains us to trade honest response for smooth surfaces.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Frank
Add to List






