"In short, I'm not sure that the abortion problem can be solved by legislation. I think it can only be solved through moral persuasion"
About this Quote
Campolo’s line sidesteps the culture-war fantasy that a sufficiently forceful law can settle a morally explosive question. As a clergyman, he’s not denying that abortion is a moral issue; he’s arguing that the real battleground is upstream from the courthouse, in the messy terrain where people form convictions, fear consequences, and make decisions under pressure. “In short” signals pastoral pragmatism: this isn’t abstract theology, it’s a hard-earned conclusion drawn from watching real lives collide with doctrine.
The intent is double-edged. On one side, he’s implicitly critiquing political Christians who treat legislation as a shortcut to righteousness. On the other, he’s warning secular audiences that legal victories don’t dissolve moral conflict; they can harden it. “Solved” is doing a lot of work. Abortion isn’t a math problem with a single correct answer; it’s a social problem with incentives, narratives, and power. Campolo reframes “solution” as cultural transformation rather than coercion.
The subtext is also strategic: moral persuasion is a way to keep pro-life convictions while resisting punitive politics. It suggests persuasion through community support, sex education, contraception access, economic security, adoption reform - the kinds of interventions that reduce abortions without turning women into defendants. Coming from a late-20th-century evangelical voice often associated with the “evangelical left,” the context matters: this is a bid to reclaim moral seriousness without letting it be monopolized by criminalization. It’s theology translated into public ethics, with a quiet admission that law can regulate behavior, but it can’t manufacture consent.
The intent is double-edged. On one side, he’s implicitly critiquing political Christians who treat legislation as a shortcut to righteousness. On the other, he’s warning secular audiences that legal victories don’t dissolve moral conflict; they can harden it. “Solved” is doing a lot of work. Abortion isn’t a math problem with a single correct answer; it’s a social problem with incentives, narratives, and power. Campolo reframes “solution” as cultural transformation rather than coercion.
The subtext is also strategic: moral persuasion is a way to keep pro-life convictions while resisting punitive politics. It suggests persuasion through community support, sex education, contraception access, economic security, adoption reform - the kinds of interventions that reduce abortions without turning women into defendants. Coming from a late-20th-century evangelical voice often associated with the “evangelical left,” the context matters: this is a bid to reclaim moral seriousness without letting it be monopolized by criminalization. It’s theology translated into public ethics, with a quiet admission that law can regulate behavior, but it can’t manufacture consent.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Tony
Add to List

