"In short, our response as a party should be to work to solve the crises that produce crisis pregnancies, and work to make life worth living for mother and child, rather than victimize the child as a way of dealing with the crisis"
About this Quote
Casey frames abortion politics as triage for a broken society, then refuses the shortcut. The line is built to sound practical and morally serious at once: “In short” promises managerial clarity, while “crises that produce crisis pregnancies” shifts the argument upstream, away from individual blame and toward conditions a party can legislate. He’s not just saying “be pro-life.” He’s insisting the only credible pro-life posture is material, not merely symbolic: wages, health care, housing, childcare, workplace protections, prenatal and postnatal support. “Make life worth living” is the tell. It’s an implicit critique of politicians who champion birth while tolerating misery afterward.
The subtext is intra-party combat. Casey, a Democrat and prominent anti-abortion figure, is staking out a pro-life identity that can live inside a liberal economic agenda. By saying “our response as a party,” he’s arguing that the party’s brand should be competence and compassion, not moral policing. He also smuggles in a rebuke of the punitive turn in abortion debates: the problem isn’t only the procedure, it’s the temptation to treat the fetus as expendable when society fails the pregnant person.
“Victimize the child” is the hard edge, designed to moralize without sounding theocratic. It casts abortion as violence while keeping the proposed remedy secular and policy-heavy. Contextually, this reads like a late-20th-century attempt to hold together a coalition fraying under culture-war pressure: keep the moral language, but tether it to a welfare-state promise. The persuasive move is simple: if you won’t fix the crisis, don’t claim righteousness about its outcomes.
The subtext is intra-party combat. Casey, a Democrat and prominent anti-abortion figure, is staking out a pro-life identity that can live inside a liberal economic agenda. By saying “our response as a party,” he’s arguing that the party’s brand should be competence and compassion, not moral policing. He also smuggles in a rebuke of the punitive turn in abortion debates: the problem isn’t only the procedure, it’s the temptation to treat the fetus as expendable when society fails the pregnant person.
“Victimize the child” is the hard edge, designed to moralize without sounding theocratic. It casts abortion as violence while keeping the proposed remedy secular and policy-heavy. Contextually, this reads like a late-20th-century attempt to hold together a coalition fraying under culture-war pressure: keep the moral language, but tether it to a welfare-state promise. The persuasive move is simple: if you won’t fix the crisis, don’t claim righteousness about its outcomes.
Quote Details
| Topic | Family |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
