"In teaching man, experimental science results in lessening his pride more and more by proving to him every day that primary causes, like the objective reality of things, will be hidden from him forever and that he can only know relations"
About this Quote
Experimental science, for Claude Bernard, is less a triumphal march than a long, elegant humiliation. The line is doing double duty: it sells the laboratory as a moral education while quietly stripping the scientist of metaphysical swagger. Each experiment, he suggests, is a small corrective to the oldest human habit, mistaking explanatory confidence for access to the universe's foundations.
The key move is the demotion of "primary causes" and even "objective reality" to permanently out-of-reach. Bernard isn't flirting with mysticism; he's making a practical argument about what science can responsibly claim. In the 19th century, physiology and medicine were trying to professionalize themselves against both speculative philosophy and vitalism - the idea that life required some extra, non-material spark. Bernard's method-first worldview rejects grand stories about what life "really is" and insists on what can be tested: relations, dependencies, regularities.
Subtextually, that modesty is power. By conceding that the "why" at the bottom may never be ours, Bernard protects the "how" that yields results: controlled variables, repeatable effects, predictive models. It's a rebuke to the vanity of total explanation and a defense of a humbler, more durable authority. Science earns trust not by claiming omniscience, but by narrowing its promises and keeping them.
One note: Bernard was a pioneering physiologist rather than a psychologist, and the quote reads like a manifesto for experimental medicine - a discipline staking its legitimacy on disciplined ignorance.
The key move is the demotion of "primary causes" and even "objective reality" to permanently out-of-reach. Bernard isn't flirting with mysticism; he's making a practical argument about what science can responsibly claim. In the 19th century, physiology and medicine were trying to professionalize themselves against both speculative philosophy and vitalism - the idea that life required some extra, non-material spark. Bernard's method-first worldview rejects grand stories about what life "really is" and insists on what can be tested: relations, dependencies, regularities.
Subtextually, that modesty is power. By conceding that the "why" at the bottom may never be ours, Bernard protects the "how" that yields results: controlled variables, repeatable effects, predictive models. It's a rebuke to the vanity of total explanation and a defense of a humbler, more durable authority. Science earns trust not by claiming omniscience, but by narrowing its promises and keeping them.
One note: Bernard was a pioneering physiologist rather than a psychologist, and the quote reads like a manifesto for experimental medicine - a discipline staking its legitimacy on disciplined ignorance.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|
More Quotes by Claude
Add to List



