"In the case of Five-O, I believe it was a combination of many ingredients - timing, chemistry, Hawaii"
About this Quote
MacArthur’s answer has the tidy modesty of an actor who knows you’re fishing for a single mythic reason a hit becomes a hit. Instead, he hands you a recipe: “many ingredients.” It’s a gentle refusal of the lone-genius narrative, and it also protects the show from the usual postmortem trap where success gets flattened into one “secret.” By naming timing, chemistry, and Hawaii, he sketches a whole ecology of television stardom in the late-60s/early-70s: the moment, the people, the place.
“Timing” is industry shorthand for alignment between a show and the audience’s mood. Hawaii Five-O landed when America was anxious and fascinated by authority, order, and mobility; a police procedural could feel like reassurance, and the weekly case structure made it easy to drop in. “Chemistry” is the least measurable but most truthful ingredient: ensemble electricity can’t be manufactured, only caught. It also subtly credits the cast and crew without singling anyone out, a diplomatic move in a business built on bruised egos.
Then there’s “Hawaii,” which reads like setting but functions like brand. The location sold escapism, spectacle, and a kind of sunlit legitimacy; it wasn’t just backdrop, it was production value and fantasy packaged as routine. The subtext is that the show’s power wasn’t only in plots or performances, but in the way it let viewers travel without leaving the couch. MacArthur frames success as atmospheric: a coincidence of conditions that can’t be replicated on command, only recognized after the fact.
“Timing” is industry shorthand for alignment between a show and the audience’s mood. Hawaii Five-O landed when America was anxious and fascinated by authority, order, and mobility; a police procedural could feel like reassurance, and the weekly case structure made it easy to drop in. “Chemistry” is the least measurable but most truthful ingredient: ensemble electricity can’t be manufactured, only caught. It also subtly credits the cast and crew without singling anyone out, a diplomatic move in a business built on bruised egos.
Then there’s “Hawaii,” which reads like setting but functions like brand. The location sold escapism, spectacle, and a kind of sunlit legitimacy; it wasn’t just backdrop, it was production value and fantasy packaged as routine. The subtext is that the show’s power wasn’t only in plots or performances, but in the way it let viewers travel without leaving the couch. MacArthur frames success as atmospheric: a coincidence of conditions that can’t be replicated on command, only recognized after the fact.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by James
Add to List





