"In the cold, shivering twilight, preceding the daybreak of civilization, the dominating emotion of man was fear"
About this Quote
Harris paints pre-civilization as a body in mid-shiver: not noble savagery, not pastoral innocence, but a twilight where instinct runs the government. The line works because it’s less anthropology than argument. By staging early humanity in “cold, shivering twilight,” he primes the reader to accept civilization as sunrise: warmth, clarity, safety. Fear becomes the original currency, the emotion that explains everything that follows - gods, laws, tribes, taboos - and it’s hard to miss the lawyerly move here. If fear is the starting condition, then institutions are not mere ornament; they’re life-support.
The subtext is both sympathetic and strategic. Harris isn’t condemning early humans as primitive; he’s diagnosing the pressure that builds society. “Dominating emotion” implies a hierarchy inside the psyche, a single force that crowds out curiosity or compassion. That’s a persuasive simplification, the kind that makes social cooperation sound not idealistic but necessary. It also quietly flatters modern readers: if civilization is daybreak, we’re living in the light, beneficiaries of progress that tames the oldest panic.
Context matters: Harris, best known as the founder of Rotary International, wrote in an era when “civilization” was often treated as a moral project - something built through professional ethics, civic clubs, and orderly commerce. Read that way, the sentence is a mission statement disguised as history. Fear is the problem; organized community is the remedy. The chill of twilight isn’t just prehistory. It’s what returns whenever social trust collapses, and Harris is selling the sunrise back to you.
The subtext is both sympathetic and strategic. Harris isn’t condemning early humans as primitive; he’s diagnosing the pressure that builds society. “Dominating emotion” implies a hierarchy inside the psyche, a single force that crowds out curiosity or compassion. That’s a persuasive simplification, the kind that makes social cooperation sound not idealistic but necessary. It also quietly flatters modern readers: if civilization is daybreak, we’re living in the light, beneficiaries of progress that tames the oldest panic.
Context matters: Harris, best known as the founder of Rotary International, wrote in an era when “civilization” was often treated as a moral project - something built through professional ethics, civic clubs, and orderly commerce. Read that way, the sentence is a mission statement disguised as history. Fear is the problem; organized community is the remedy. The chill of twilight isn’t just prehistory. It’s what returns whenever social trust collapses, and Harris is selling the sunrise back to you.
Quote Details
| Topic | Fear |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Paul
Add to List





