"In the long-run every Government is the exact symbol of its People, with their wisdom and unwisdom; we have to say, Like People like Government"
About this Quote
Carlyle doesn’t flatter the public with talk of bad rulers imposed on innocent masses; he indicts the whole civic ecosystem. “Exact symbol” is doing a lot of work here: government isn’t just an institution but a mirror, a public self-portrait hung in the town square. If you don’t like the picture, Carlyle implies, stop blaming the frame.
The phrasing “wisdom and unwisdom” has the snap of a moral ledger. He’s not claiming people are simply wise or foolish; he’s stressing the mixture, the daily compromises, the appetites for comfort, spectacle, and easy answers that inevitably get laundered into policy. The subtext is harshly anti-scapegoat. Corruption, incompetence, cruelty, inertia: these aren’t alien forces. They’re social habits that have found a bureaucracy.
Context matters. Carlyle is a 19th-century British writer watching democratization, industrial upheaval, and the fraying authority of old elites. He mistrusted mass politics and was drawn to “great man” leadership, but this line isn’t an argument for aristocratic rescue so much as a warning about collective responsibility. Representation, in his view, is not merely electoral arithmetic; it’s cultural. What a society rewards - what it tolerates, laughs off, demands, excuses - will eventually harden into governance.
It works because it weaponizes a proverb (“Like people, like government”) into a diagnosis: politics is downstream from character. That’s bracing, and a little merciless, precisely because it denies everyone the comfort of purity.
The phrasing “wisdom and unwisdom” has the snap of a moral ledger. He’s not claiming people are simply wise or foolish; he’s stressing the mixture, the daily compromises, the appetites for comfort, spectacle, and easy answers that inevitably get laundered into policy. The subtext is harshly anti-scapegoat. Corruption, incompetence, cruelty, inertia: these aren’t alien forces. They’re social habits that have found a bureaucracy.
Context matters. Carlyle is a 19th-century British writer watching democratization, industrial upheaval, and the fraying authority of old elites. He mistrusted mass politics and was drawn to “great man” leadership, but this line isn’t an argument for aristocratic rescue so much as a warning about collective responsibility. Representation, in his view, is not merely electoral arithmetic; it’s cultural. What a society rewards - what it tolerates, laughs off, demands, excuses - will eventually harden into governance.
It works because it weaponizes a proverb (“Like people, like government”) into a diagnosis: politics is downstream from character. That’s bracing, and a little merciless, precisely because it denies everyone the comfort of purity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List
