"In the true sense one's native land, with its background of tradition, early impressions, reminiscences and other things dear to one, is not enough to make sensitive human beings feel at home"
About this Quote
Goldman takes a sentimental staple of nationhood - the idea that birthplace plus memory equals belonging - and snaps it in half. Her phrasing is deliberately cool: "in the true sense" signals she is not rejecting nostalgia, she is challenging its political use. Tradition and "early impressions" are the soft materials out of which states manufacture hard loyalties. Goldman itemizes them like evidence in a case file, then insists they still may not be "enough" for "sensitive human beings" to feel at home. Sensitivity here is a moral upgrade, not fragility: the more awake you are to coercion, hypocrisy, and injustice, the less a flag can anesthetize you.
The subtext is an immigrant's argument against compulsory gratitude. In the early 20th century, Goldman was hounded, jailed, and ultimately deported from the United States for anarchism and anti-war organizing. "Native land" is not just a geography for her; it's a pressure system. The quote refuses the common bargain offered to dissenters: accept the nation as family, and your complaints become personal betrayals. Goldman flips that script. Home isn't inherited; it's earned through freedom, solidarity, and the right to live without being policed into patriotism.
There's also a quiet cosmopolitan provocation: if belonging is contingent on justice, then exile becomes an ethical stance, not a tragedy. Goldman is telling the reader that homesickness can be political clarity - a sign that your conscience still works.
The subtext is an immigrant's argument against compulsory gratitude. In the early 20th century, Goldman was hounded, jailed, and ultimately deported from the United States for anarchism and anti-war organizing. "Native land" is not just a geography for her; it's a pressure system. The quote refuses the common bargain offered to dissenters: accept the nation as family, and your complaints become personal betrayals. Goldman flips that script. Home isn't inherited; it's earned through freedom, solidarity, and the right to live without being policed into patriotism.
There's also a quiet cosmopolitan provocation: if belonging is contingent on justice, then exile becomes an ethical stance, not a tragedy. Goldman is telling the reader that homesickness can be political clarity - a sign that your conscience still works.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nostalgia |
|---|
More Quotes by Emma
Add to List




