"In their rules there was only one clause: Do what you will"
About this Quote
A utopia with a single rule is never just a utopia; it is a dare. Rabelais, a former friar with a taste for the carnivalesque and a hard-earned suspicion of sanctimony, gives us the Abbey of Theleme’s famously weightless charter: "Do what you will". On the surface it reads like permission, a Renaissance mic drop against monastic regimentation. Underneath, it’s a scalpel aimed at the idea that virtue can be manufactured by external constraint.
The line works because it reverses the usual moral logic of religious institutions. Traditional cloisters assume people are wayward by default and must be fenced in by vows, schedules, silence, and surveillance. Rabelais proposes the opposite: put good people in decent conditions and they’ll self-govern. His clause is less libertinism than elite humanism. Theleme isn’t open-admission; it’s populated by the already "well-born" and well-educated. Freedom here is a reward for the trustworthy, not a right extended to the messy masses. That elitist subtext is the catch that keeps the joke from becoming a Hallmark slogan.
Context matters: Rabelais is writing in a France tense with ecclesiastical authority, scholastic pedantry, and the early shocks of Reformation debate. As a clergyman, he can’t simply torch the monastery on the page; he parodies it into irrelevance. Theleme’s single clause is satire disguised as aspiration: a fantasy of conscience unpoliced, and a critique of institutions that confuse obedience with goodness.
The line works because it reverses the usual moral logic of religious institutions. Traditional cloisters assume people are wayward by default and must be fenced in by vows, schedules, silence, and surveillance. Rabelais proposes the opposite: put good people in decent conditions and they’ll self-govern. His clause is less libertinism than elite humanism. Theleme isn’t open-admission; it’s populated by the already "well-born" and well-educated. Freedom here is a reward for the trustworthy, not a right extended to the messy masses. That elitist subtext is the catch that keeps the joke from becoming a Hallmark slogan.
Context matters: Rabelais is writing in a France tense with ecclesiastical authority, scholastic pedantry, and the early shocks of Reformation debate. As a clergyman, he can’t simply torch the monastery on the page; he parodies it into irrelevance. Theleme’s single clause is satire disguised as aspiration: a fantasy of conscience unpoliced, and a critique of institutions that confuse obedience with goodness.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Gargantua and Pantagruel (François Rabelais, 16th century) — Abbey of Thélème motto "Fay ce que vouldras" commonly translated as "Do what thou wilt"/"Do what you will". |
More Quotes by Francois
Add to List










