"In violence, we forget who we are"
About this Quote
Violence, McCarthy suggests, is less a rupture than an amnesia. The line doesn’t moralize with sermon-y certainty; it indicts with a cool, devastating precision. “Forget” is the trapdoor word: it implies that identity isn’t a fixed possession but a practiced discipline, something maintained through habits, boundaries, and memory. Violence doesn’t merely harm an opponent; it dissolves the self’s continuity. You become someone else in the act, and that “someone else” is often frighteningly easy to inhabit.
McCarthy, a novelist and critic with an unsentimental eye for American hypocrisy, wrote in the shadow of the mid-century’s organized brutality: world war, ideological purges, the blunt logic of state power dressed up as necessity. Her work repeatedly skewers the narratives people tell to excuse their appetites and ambitions. This sentence distills that larger project. It points to how violence arrives with a story attached: defense, justice, righteousness, history’s demands. The subtext is that these stories are convenient forms of self-forgetting. They let individuals and nations outsource conscience to adrenaline and group identity.
The phrasing is also deliberately collective: “we,” not “they.” No safe distance, no monster-making. McCarthy’s intent is to deny the reader the comfort of exceptionalism. Violence isn’t an alien pathology; it’s a human shortcut, a way to stop thinking, to stop recognizing complexity, to stop recognizing yourself. The sting is that the loss isn’t only ethical. It’s personal: violence makes you narrower, and then tells you that narrowing was strength.
McCarthy, a novelist and critic with an unsentimental eye for American hypocrisy, wrote in the shadow of the mid-century’s organized brutality: world war, ideological purges, the blunt logic of state power dressed up as necessity. Her work repeatedly skewers the narratives people tell to excuse their appetites and ambitions. This sentence distills that larger project. It points to how violence arrives with a story attached: defense, justice, righteousness, history’s demands. The subtext is that these stories are convenient forms of self-forgetting. They let individuals and nations outsource conscience to adrenaline and group identity.
The phrasing is also deliberately collective: “we,” not “they.” No safe distance, no monster-making. McCarthy’s intent is to deny the reader the comfort of exceptionalism. Violence isn’t an alien pathology; it’s a human shortcut, a way to stop thinking, to stop recognizing complexity, to stop recognizing yourself. The sting is that the loss isn’t only ethical. It’s personal: violence makes you narrower, and then tells you that narrowing was strength.
Quote Details
| Topic | Peace |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
McCarthy, Mary. (2026, January 15). In violence, we forget who we are. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/in-violence-we-forget-who-we-are-68796/
Chicago Style
McCarthy, Mary. "In violence, we forget who we are." FixQuotes. January 15, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/in-violence-we-forget-who-we-are-68796/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"In violence, we forget who we are." FixQuotes, 15 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/in-violence-we-forget-who-we-are-68796/. Accessed 13 Feb. 2026.
More Quotes by Mary
Add to List




