"Incidentally, why was it that none of all the pious ever discovered psycho-analysis? Why did it have to wait for a completely godless Jew?"
About this Quote
The second sentence sharpens into cultural provocation. "Completely godless" is not just self-description; it's bait, a challenge to the idea that spiritual insight requires faith. And "Jew" is doing heavy historical work. Freud is writing as a secular Jewish thinker in a Europe where Jewishness was routinely marked as outsider status and where psychoanalysis was attacked as a "Jewish" intrusion into Christian moral life. He turns that stigma into leverage: the outsider sees what insiders naturalize. The subtext is that piety can function as a defense mechanism - a ready-made story that keeps unacceptable impulses safely untranslated.
There's also Freud's own brand management here. He casts psychoanalysis as anti-clerical modernity: not confession but interpretation, not absolution but explanation. The sting is that the faithful had centuries of practice listening to private shame, and still it took a "godless Jew" to treat it as evidence rather than a verdict.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Freud, Sigmund. (2026, January 18). Incidentally, why was it that none of all the pious ever discovered psycho-analysis? Why did it have to wait for a completely godless Jew? FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/incidentally-why-was-it-that-none-of-all-the-21157/
Chicago Style
Freud, Sigmund. "Incidentally, why was it that none of all the pious ever discovered psycho-analysis? Why did it have to wait for a completely godless Jew?" FixQuotes. January 18, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/incidentally-why-was-it-that-none-of-all-the-21157/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Incidentally, why was it that none of all the pious ever discovered psycho-analysis? Why did it have to wait for a completely godless Jew?" FixQuotes, 18 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/incidentally-why-was-it-that-none-of-all-the-21157/. Accessed 22 Feb. 2026.






