"Incomprehensible jargon is the hallmark of a profession"
About this Quote
A profession doesn’t just sell expertise; it sells distance. Brewster’s line skewers that little theatrical gap between the initiated and everyone else, the way dense language can turn ordinary judgment into a gated community. “Hallmark” is the sting: not an accident, not a bad habit, but a signature feature. He’s pointing to jargon as credentialing technology, a linguistic uniform that signals authority even when it obscures meaning.
Coming from an educator and longtime university president (and later a diplomat), the target isn’t only medicine, law, or academia; it’s the institutional reflex to protect status by making knowledge hard to audit. Jargon promises precision, but it also offers plausible deniability. If outcomes disappoint, the language can always be reinterpreted, the blame redistributed, the questioner made to feel unqualified for having asked. The subtext is moral as much as stylistic: opacity becomes a way to dodge accountability while still demanding deference.
The quote lands because it flips a common defense. Professionals often claim complexity forces technical speech. Brewster suggests the reverse incentive: complexity is partly manufactured, because incomprehensibility performs social work. It filters outsiders, bonds insiders, and turns a craft into a caste. In the classroom and the committee meeting alike, the cleanest proof of mastery is usually the ability to make the hard intelligible. Brewster’s cynicism is a reminder that when language stops serving understanding, it starts serving power.
Coming from an educator and longtime university president (and later a diplomat), the target isn’t only medicine, law, or academia; it’s the institutional reflex to protect status by making knowledge hard to audit. Jargon promises precision, but it also offers plausible deniability. If outcomes disappoint, the language can always be reinterpreted, the blame redistributed, the questioner made to feel unqualified for having asked. The subtext is moral as much as stylistic: opacity becomes a way to dodge accountability while still demanding deference.
The quote lands because it flips a common defense. Professionals often claim complexity forces technical speech. Brewster suggests the reverse incentive: complexity is partly manufactured, because incomprehensibility performs social work. It filters outsiders, bonds insiders, and turns a craft into a caste. In the classroom and the committee meeting alike, the cleanest proof of mastery is usually the ability to make the hard intelligible. Brewster’s cynicism is a reminder that when language stops serving understanding, it starts serving power.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Kingman
Add to List






