"Indubitably, magic is one of the subtlest and most difficult of the sciences and arts. There is more opportunity for errors of comprehension, judgment and practice than in any other branch of physics"
About this Quote
Crowley doesn’t sell magic as a mood or a mystery; he sells it as a discipline with lab-grade stakes. “Indubitably” is doing quiet propaganda work up front, a mock-academic throat-clear meant to disarm skepticism by sounding like a man in a white coat. Then comes the real pivot: magic is framed as “one of the subtlest and most difficult of the sciences and arts.” That hybrid phrasing is the tell. Crowley wants occult practice to borrow the legitimacy of science while keeping the prestige of art: repeatable technique plus individual genius, experiment plus style.
The subtext is a defensive maneuver against the era’s easy caricatures of the occult as parlor trick or credulity. By admitting how error-prone it is - “more opportunity for errors of comprehension, judgment and practice” - he anticipates the critic’s strongest argument (that magic doesn’t work) and flips it: failure isn’t evidence against the system; it’s evidence you did it wrong. That’s a classic move in closed epistemologies, but Crowley performs it with the rhetoric of rigorous inquiry rather than faith.
The kicker is “any other branch of physics.” Crowley is parasitizing the authority of early-20th-century science, when physics was suddenly weird enough (radioactivity, relativity, quantum tremors) to make the public newly receptive to invisible forces. He’s positioning the magician as an expert of the unseen - not a crank at the margins, but a specialist operating where measurement, perception, and will can most easily betray you.
The subtext is a defensive maneuver against the era’s easy caricatures of the occult as parlor trick or credulity. By admitting how error-prone it is - “more opportunity for errors of comprehension, judgment and practice” - he anticipates the critic’s strongest argument (that magic doesn’t work) and flips it: failure isn’t evidence against the system; it’s evidence you did it wrong. That’s a classic move in closed epistemologies, but Crowley performs it with the rhetoric of rigorous inquiry rather than faith.
The kicker is “any other branch of physics.” Crowley is parasitizing the authority of early-20th-century science, when physics was suddenly weird enough (radioactivity, relativity, quantum tremors) to make the public newly receptive to invisible forces. He’s positioning the magician as an expert of the unseen - not a crank at the margins, but a specialist operating where measurement, perception, and will can most easily betray you.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Aleister
Add to List






