"Inductive reason, which alone makes man master of his environment, is an achievement; and when once born it must be reinforced by inhibiting the growth of other modes of knowledge"
About this Quote
Iqbal frames inductive reason less as a neutral tool than as a hard-won political technology: the one mental habit that turns a human being from passenger to engineer of his surroundings. Calling it an "achievement" is doing quiet work here. It implies scarcity, discipline, even historical contingency - as if reason is not humanity's default setting but a fragile invention that can be lost. For a poet-philosopher writing in the shadow of colonial modernity, that matters: the West's material dominance had been justified as the victory of "science", while colonized societies were caricatured as trapped in tradition. Iqbal refuses the caricature but accepts the battlefield. If mastery of environment is the metric of power, inductive reason becomes a kind of emancipation.
The provocation is the second clause: reason, once born, "must be reinforced by inhibiting the growth of other modes of knowledge". That's the line that bites. The subtext is not simply pro-science; it's about attention, institutional priorities, and the ecology of ideas. Societies can't maximize every epistemology at once. Mystical intuition, inherited authority, metaphysical speculation - these can be culturally rich yet, in Iqbal's calculus, politically disabling if they crowd out methods that produce verifiable leverage over the world.
There's also an anxiety hiding in the syntax. "Must be reinforced" sounds like a defense against relapse, as if older modes of knowing have a gravitational pull. In that tension, Iqbal sounds modern in the most unsettling way: liberation requires gatekeeping. The quote works because it smuggles a revolutionary demand (think scientifically, or be ruled) inside an apparently sober philosophy of knowledge.
The provocation is the second clause: reason, once born, "must be reinforced by inhibiting the growth of other modes of knowledge". That's the line that bites. The subtext is not simply pro-science; it's about attention, institutional priorities, and the ecology of ideas. Societies can't maximize every epistemology at once. Mystical intuition, inherited authority, metaphysical speculation - these can be culturally rich yet, in Iqbal's calculus, politically disabling if they crowd out methods that produce verifiable leverage over the world.
There's also an anxiety hiding in the syntax. "Must be reinforced" sounds like a defense against relapse, as if older modes of knowing have a gravitational pull. In that tension, Iqbal sounds modern in the most unsettling way: liberation requires gatekeeping. The quote works because it smuggles a revolutionary demand (think scientifically, or be ruled) inside an apparently sober philosophy of knowledge.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Muhammed
Add to List










