"Ironically, we live in times that are awash in authentic sacred music"
About this Quote
A clergyman calling his own moment "ironically" awash in authentic sacred music is doing more than praising a renaissance. He is laying a trap for complacency. The line turns on a quiet contradiction: if sacred music is truly abundant and "authentic", why the need to announce it with a wince? The implied answer is that the culture is hearing the right sounds while living the wrong life. Morris uses the language of surplus ("awash") to suggest not triumph but saturation: plenty can dull reverence as easily as it can nourish it.
In the 19th century, churches were being reshaped by industrial modernity and mass print. Hymnals multiplied, choirs professionalized, organs and harmoniums standardized worship, and "ancient" repertoire could be revived and circulated with new ease. Authenticity becomes a badge you can acquire, reproduce, and sell. That is the irony Morris is pointing at: the very mechanisms that preserve sacred tradition also risk turning it into tasteful atmosphere, a moral accessory rather than a lived discipline.
The phrase "authentic sacred music" also signals a policing of boundaries. It hints at battles over what counts as properly devotional versus merely popular, sentimental, or theatrical. By stressing authenticity, Morris is likely defending a certain strain of church music (older, restrained, doctrinally aligned) against showier revival styles. The subtext is pastoral and anxious: the sanctuary may be filling with correct harmonies even as attention, humility, and faith drift elsewhere.
In the 19th century, churches were being reshaped by industrial modernity and mass print. Hymnals multiplied, choirs professionalized, organs and harmoniums standardized worship, and "ancient" repertoire could be revived and circulated with new ease. Authenticity becomes a badge you can acquire, reproduce, and sell. That is the irony Morris is pointing at: the very mechanisms that preserve sacred tradition also risk turning it into tasteful atmosphere, a moral accessory rather than a lived discipline.
The phrase "authentic sacred music" also signals a policing of boundaries. It hints at battles over what counts as properly devotional versus merely popular, sentimental, or theatrical. By stressing authenticity, Morris is likely defending a certain strain of church music (older, restrained, doctrinally aligned) against showier revival styles. The subtext is pastoral and anxious: the sanctuary may be filling with correct harmonies even as attention, humility, and faith drift elsewhere.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Richard
Add to List





