"Is a woman raped every three minutes or every six minutes? It is far too much, whatever it is"
About this Quote
The pivot from a grim statistic to a moral indictment is the whole move here. Patricia Ireland isn’t doing math; she’s refusing to let the debate hide inside math. By posing the question - every three minutes or every six? - she mimics the way institutions, media, and even well-meaning advocates can get trapped in the procedural comfort of “getting the number right,” as if precision were the same as progress. Then she yanks the reader back: “It is far too much, whatever it is.” The line lands like a slammed door.
The intent is tactical. Activists routinely face a hostile or skeptical audience that will seize on any discrepancy to discredit the entire claim. Ireland anticipates the gotcha: if the figure is challenged, the urgency shouldn’t evaporate. Her phrasing exposes a familiar bad-faith maneuver in public argument: demanding perfect data as a prerequisite for empathy or action, while the underlying harm continues uninterrupted.
The subtext is also a critique of statistical spectatorship - the way violence against women gets processed as an abstract social problem rather than a continual, intimate catastrophe. “Whatever it is” doesn’t dismiss evidence; it indicts the tendency to treat rape as a rounding error in policy conversation.
Context matters: Ireland’s era of feminist organizing was shaped by fights to name sexual violence publicly, reform laws, and push institutions to take survivors seriously. The quote is built for that battlefield: short, quotable, and calibrated to shame complacency without softening the reality it points to.
The intent is tactical. Activists routinely face a hostile or skeptical audience that will seize on any discrepancy to discredit the entire claim. Ireland anticipates the gotcha: if the figure is challenged, the urgency shouldn’t evaporate. Her phrasing exposes a familiar bad-faith maneuver in public argument: demanding perfect data as a prerequisite for empathy or action, while the underlying harm continues uninterrupted.
The subtext is also a critique of statistical spectatorship - the way violence against women gets processed as an abstract social problem rather than a continual, intimate catastrophe. “Whatever it is” doesn’t dismiss evidence; it indicts the tendency to treat rape as a rounding error in policy conversation.
Context matters: Ireland’s era of feminist organizing was shaped by fights to name sexual violence publicly, reform laws, and push institutions to take survivors seriously. The quote is built for that battlefield: short, quotable, and calibrated to shame complacency without softening the reality it points to.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Patricia
Add to List





