Freedom Quote by Matt Shea

"Is there any media here? A couple? Excellent. I want to ask you, I don't know what persuasion you are, but would you like to go outside to a 1st Amendment zone? No! So did it make sense to have a 1st Amendment zone in Nevada? No, of course not. That's ridiculous. If we're talking about one of the most egregious things that happened down there, it was the 1st Amendment zone in Nevada"

Matt Shea, Lawyer

About this Quote

He starts by hunting for cameras, then uses them as props. "Is there any media here? A couple? Excellent". The setup is pure performance: identify an audience with amplification power, then stage a mini call-and-response that lets him look like the only adult in the room. Even the feigned uncertainty - "I don't know what persuasion you are" - reads less like humility than a baited compliment, a way to flatter reporters into playing along as neutral arbiters.

The "1st Amendment zone" becomes his perfect villain because it sounds bureaucratic and absurd on its face. Asking journalists if they want to go to one is a rhetorical trap: of course they don't. By making the press answer for their own inconvenience, he collapses a complex civil-liberties debate into a single relatable irritation. The repeated "No!... No, of course not. That's ridiculous" is doing the work of argument without actually supplying evidence. It's moral certainty delivered at the tempo of talk radio.

Subtext: he isn't just defending free speech; he's asserting that the state has no legitimacy to manage protest, dissent, or public space at all when it becomes inconvenient to his side. The phrase "one of the most egregious things" escalates the complaint into a grievance hierarchy, nudging the listener to treat "designated protest areas" not as a contested tactic but as an obvious scandal. Contextually, "1st Amendment zones" evoke post-9/11 security theater and political events where dissent was corralled out of sight. Shea's move is to harness that history, then use the media's own self-interest to validate his outrage on cue.

Quote Details

Topic	Freedom
Source	Help us find the source
Cite

More Quotes by Matt Add to List

About the Author

Matt Shea

Matt Shea (born April 18, 1974) is a Lawyer from USA.

43 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

"Nevada's one of the most conservative states in the Union, but you can do what you want in Vegas and nobody judges you"

Drew Carey, Actor

"When I began we did not really have a lot of First Amendment law. It is really surprising to think of it this way, but a lot of the law - most of the law that relates to the First Amendment freedom of the press in America - is really within living memory"

Floyd Abrams, Lawyer

"As to the media, they are protected by the First Amendment, as they should be"

L. Neil Smith, Writer

"If the First Amendment means anything, it means that a state has no business telling a man, sitting alone in his house, what books he may read or what films he may watch"

Thurgood Marshall, Judge

Thurgood Marshall

"The First Amendment rejects red tape, cover-up and double-speak"

Roy Barnes, Politician

"I don't think the First Amendment trumps everything"

Tom Keith, Radio host

Tom Keith

"The First Amendment has the same role in my life as a citizen and a writer as the sun has in our ecosystem"

Michael Chabon, Author

"The Washington Times wrote a story questioning the authenticity of some of the suggestions made about me in Silent Coup. But as a believer in the First Amendment, I believe they have more than a right to air their views"

Bob Woodward, Journalist

Bob Woodward

"It just seems to be a human trait to want to protect the speech of people with whom we agree. For the First Amendment, that is not good enough. So it is really important that we protect First Amendment rights of people no matter what side of the line they are on"

Floyd Abrams, Lawyer

"In Cyberspace, the First Amendment is a local ordinance"

John Perry Barlow, Writer

John Perry Barlow

"I believe that the Framers of the Constitution made their intent clear when they wrote the First Amendment. I believe they wanted to keep the new government from endorsing one religion over another, not erase the public consciousness or common faith"

Nick Rahall, Politician

"Let me share some facts with you about the law in most of our country. California is in many ways a little different from the rest of the world, and California has better gun laws than many states, although California's need to be improved"

Michael D. Barnes, Politician

"The First Amendment is not an altar on which we must sacrifice our children, families, and community standards. Obscene material that is not protected by the First Amendment can and must be prohibited"

Orrin Hatch, Politician

"Vegas is everything that's right with America. You can do whatever you want, 24 hours a day. They've effectively legalized everything there"

Drew Carey, Actor

"The First Amendment means everything to me"

Julian Bond, Activist

"The Second Amendment is a constitutional right. I didn't make it up, the Republican Party didn't make it up. It's in the Constitution. I think it's just as important as any of the other rights in our constitution"

Marco Rubio, Politician

Marco Rubio

"Patenting and purchase of lands are absolutely vital to the health of Nevada's rural communities"

Jim Gibbons, Politician

Jim Gibbons

"I begin to feel like most Americans don't understand the First Amendment, don't understand the idea of freedom of speech, and don't understand that it's the responsibility of the citizen to speak out"

Roger Ebert, Critic

"I find this proposed amendment very, very, very, very shocking. And immoral. And, you know, if civil disobedience is the way to go about change, then I think a lot of people will be going to San Francisco"

Rosie O'Donnell, Comedian

"You know why there's a Second Amendment? In case the government fails to follow the first one"

Rush Limbaugh, Entertainer

Rush Limbaugh