"It did not come naturally; in fact, it would be difficult to conceive of any more dogmatic and less tolerant people than the first settlers on New England shores"
About this Quote
His phrasing is strategically cold. "It did not come naturally" reads like a rebuttal in a brief, pushing back against the popular assumption that freedom and tolerance simply sprouted from the colonial soil. Then he tightens the screw with "difficult to conceive", a near-absolute that courts the reader into trying - and failing - to imagine a more dogmatic group. The rhetoric is prosecutorial: no anecdotes, no melodrama, just a devastating comparative claim that leaves the myth looking naive.
The subtext is about power, not piety. These settlers, often celebrated for fleeing persecution, quickly built systems that punished dissent, policed belief, and treated deviation as a civic threat. Harris is pointing to a recurring American pattern: groups that arrive demanding liberty frequently turn, once they have leverage, into administrators of orthodoxy.
Context matters, too. Writing from the late 19th/early 20th century, Harris is speaking in a period when Americans were renegotiating what "tolerance" should mean amid immigration, religious diversity, and modern reforms. His point lands as a warning: if you want a freer society, you cannot outsource that work to the past, especially not to ancestors who were busy enforcing purity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Harris, Paul. (2026, January 16). It did not come naturally; in fact, it would be difficult to conceive of any more dogmatic and less tolerant people than the first settlers on New England shores. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/it-did-not-come-naturally-in-fact-it-would-be-85376/
Chicago Style
Harris, Paul. "It did not come naturally; in fact, it would be difficult to conceive of any more dogmatic and less tolerant people than the first settlers on New England shores." FixQuotes. January 16, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/it-did-not-come-naturally-in-fact-it-would-be-85376/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"It did not come naturally; in fact, it would be difficult to conceive of any more dogmatic and less tolerant people than the first settlers on New England shores." FixQuotes, 16 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/it-did-not-come-naturally-in-fact-it-would-be-85376/. Accessed 13 Feb. 2026.



