"It had never occurred to me before that music and thinking are so much alike. In fact you could say music is another way of thinking, or maybe thinking is another kind of music"
About this Quote
Le Guin collapses a hierarchy most of us absorb without noticing: that thinking is “serious” work and music is decoration. Her line refuses the split. By treating music as cognition and cognition as music, she reframes intelligence as pattern-making rather than mere argumentation. It’s a quietly radical move from a writer who spent her career questioning what a culture calls rational, civilized, or real.
The phrasing matters. “It had never occurred to me before” stages discovery, not doctrine, a signature Le Guin tactic: she invites you into an experiment instead of handing down a thesis. Then she pivots on “another way” and “another kind,” language that rejects binaries. Music isn’t an escape from thought; it’s thought with different tools: rhythm, repetition, tension and release, theme and variation. Likewise, thinking at its best has musical qualities - pacing, cadence, an ear for resonance, a sense of where to place silence.
Subtext: she’s also smuggling in a critique of Western logocentrism, the old bias that treats language-based reasoning as the only legitimate mind. Le Guin, steeped in anthropology and Taoist-inflected sensibilities, often writes toward forms of knowing that don’t dominate or dissect. Music becomes a model for non-coercive intelligence: collaborative, temporal, embodied, impossible to pin down to a single “meaning” yet undeniably structured.
Contextually, it’s an author of speculative worlds making a claim about our own: that consciousness is not a courtroom brief. It’s a composition.
The phrasing matters. “It had never occurred to me before” stages discovery, not doctrine, a signature Le Guin tactic: she invites you into an experiment instead of handing down a thesis. Then she pivots on “another way” and “another kind,” language that rejects binaries. Music isn’t an escape from thought; it’s thought with different tools: rhythm, repetition, tension and release, theme and variation. Likewise, thinking at its best has musical qualities - pacing, cadence, an ear for resonance, a sense of where to place silence.
Subtext: she’s also smuggling in a critique of Western logocentrism, the old bias that treats language-based reasoning as the only legitimate mind. Le Guin, steeped in anthropology and Taoist-inflected sensibilities, often writes toward forms of knowing that don’t dominate or dissect. Music becomes a model for non-coercive intelligence: collaborative, temporal, embodied, impossible to pin down to a single “meaning” yet undeniably structured.
Contextually, it’s an author of speculative worlds making a claim about our own: that consciousness is not a courtroom brief. It’s a composition.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Ursula
Add to List
