"It has not been for nothing that the word has remained man's principal toy and tool: without the meanings and values it sustains, all man's other tools would be worthless"
About this Quote
Mumford is quietly demolishing the macho myth that civilization is built by hard objects and hard men. The “principal toy and tool” line is a double barb: language is the serious instrument that makes society possible, and it’s also a plaything we use to rehearse identities, hierarchies, desires. “Toy” smuggles in the idea that culture isn’t just engineered; it’s improvised, contested, and sometimes childish. That mix is the point. Words let humans do something no hammer can do: coordinate shared fictions at scale.
The sentence turns on “meanings and values,” a pairing that signals Mumford’s broader project as a mid-century critic of technocracy. As an urbanist and social theorist who watched industrial modernity promise liberation and deliver mass regimentation, he insists that tools don’t arrive with built-in purpose. Machines extend capacity, but language supplies ends. A bulldozer can build housing or flatten a neighborhood; the difference is a moral and political argument conducted in words. Even “worth” is a linguistic-social category: markets, laws, professions, patents, and “progress” itself are sustained by narratives, definitions, and consent.
Subtext: if you treat language as decoration - PR, “messaging,” spin - you hand the steering wheel to whoever controls the story. Mumford is warning that a society intoxicated by gadgetry but careless with meaning becomes efficient at the wrong things. The line reads like a defense of the humanities, but sharper: it’s an indictment of tool-worship. Without words to carry values, our technologies don’t just fail to save us; they become perfectly competent instruments for emptiness or harm.
The sentence turns on “meanings and values,” a pairing that signals Mumford’s broader project as a mid-century critic of technocracy. As an urbanist and social theorist who watched industrial modernity promise liberation and deliver mass regimentation, he insists that tools don’t arrive with built-in purpose. Machines extend capacity, but language supplies ends. A bulldozer can build housing or flatten a neighborhood; the difference is a moral and political argument conducted in words. Even “worth” is a linguistic-social category: markets, laws, professions, patents, and “progress” itself are sustained by narratives, definitions, and consent.
Subtext: if you treat language as decoration - PR, “messaging,” spin - you hand the steering wheel to whoever controls the story. Mumford is warning that a society intoxicated by gadgetry but careless with meaning becomes efficient at the wrong things. The line reads like a defense of the humanities, but sharper: it’s an indictment of tool-worship. Without words to carry values, our technologies don’t just fail to save us; they become perfectly competent instruments for emptiness or harm.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Lewis
Add to List
