"It is a widely accepted notion among painters that it does not matter what one paints as long as it is well painted. This is the essence of academicism"
About this Quote
Rothko is skewering a complacent bargain: trade meaning for technique, and call it professionalism. The line starts by ventriloquizing “a widely accepted notion,” that pious consensus artists repeat to sound serious. Then he twists the knife. “As long as it is well painted” flatters craft while quietly emptying art of stakes. It’s not an argument about competence; it’s an argument about what competence is allowed to excuse.
Calling this “the essence of academicism” is a precise insult. Academicism, in Rothko’s framing, isn’t just old-school training or museum-approved realism. It’s an ideology that treats painting as a self-contained problem set: composition, finish, virtuosity, solved. Subject becomes interchangeable, even irrelevant, because the institution rewards the recognizably “well done.” The subtext is brutal: if anything can be redeemed by polish, then nothing has to risk difficulty, uncertainty, or spiritual ambition.
Context matters. Rothko comes up through figurative work and breaks toward abstraction in a moment when American art is trying to outrun European inheritance and the suffocating authority of salons, juries, and “good taste.” Abstract Expressionism wasn’t only a style shift; it was a demand that painting carry psychic and moral pressure, not just optical pleasure. Rothko’s own canvases insist that content isn’t a depicted thing but an encounter - mood as event. That’s why the quote works: it exposes “well painted” as a social credential, a way of winning approval without having to say anything that could disturb it.
Calling this “the essence of academicism” is a precise insult. Academicism, in Rothko’s framing, isn’t just old-school training or museum-approved realism. It’s an ideology that treats painting as a self-contained problem set: composition, finish, virtuosity, solved. Subject becomes interchangeable, even irrelevant, because the institution rewards the recognizably “well done.” The subtext is brutal: if anything can be redeemed by polish, then nothing has to risk difficulty, uncertainty, or spiritual ambition.
Context matters. Rothko comes up through figurative work and breaks toward abstraction in a moment when American art is trying to outrun European inheritance and the suffocating authority of salons, juries, and “good taste.” Abstract Expressionism wasn’t only a style shift; it was a demand that painting carry psychic and moral pressure, not just optical pleasure. Rothko’s own canvases insist that content isn’t a depicted thing but an encounter - mood as event. That’s why the quote works: it exposes “well painted” as a social credential, a way of winning approval without having to say anything that could disturb it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Mark
Add to List
