"It is but refusing to gratify an unreasonable or an insolent demand, and up starts a patriot"
About this Quote
A single act of “no” becomes, in Walpole’s telling, a magic trick: deny an “unreasonable or insolent demand,” and suddenly the rejected party rebrands as a patriot. The line is calibrated to puncture sanctimony. Walpole isn’t attacking patriotism as an ideal so much as the convenient, theatrical version deployed when private interest hits a public wall. It’s a statesman’s cynicism, sharpened into epigram.
The phrasing matters. “But refusing” minimizes the provocation: the government hasn’t tyrannized; it has merely withheld a favor. “Gratify” is a deliberately demeaning verb, suggesting indulgence, like feeding a child’s appetite. Then comes the comic snap of “up starts,” a little stage direction that turns political outrage into slapstick. Patriotism here is not born of principle; it “starts” like a jack-in-the-box, spring-loaded by resentment.
Context is everything: Walpole governed through patronage, coalition management, and a Parliament where influence often moved through bargains that were legal, expected, and widely suspected of being corrupt. In that world, the loudest cries of “country” virtue could be indistinguishable from sour grapes after a lost sinecure or a blocked contract. The quote functions as defensive realism from a leader constantly accused of selling out the nation: he flips the accusation by implying his opponents are the ones instrumentalizing the nation.
Subtextually, it’s a warning about rhetoric’s cheapest power. “Patriot” is not a moral category but a costume anyone can put on once self-interest needs a halo. Walpole’s sting is enduring because it targets the mechanism, not the ideology: grievance plus branding equals virtue.
The phrasing matters. “But refusing” minimizes the provocation: the government hasn’t tyrannized; it has merely withheld a favor. “Gratify” is a deliberately demeaning verb, suggesting indulgence, like feeding a child’s appetite. Then comes the comic snap of “up starts,” a little stage direction that turns political outrage into slapstick. Patriotism here is not born of principle; it “starts” like a jack-in-the-box, spring-loaded by resentment.
Context is everything: Walpole governed through patronage, coalition management, and a Parliament where influence often moved through bargains that were legal, expected, and widely suspected of being corrupt. In that world, the loudest cries of “country” virtue could be indistinguishable from sour grapes after a lost sinecure or a blocked contract. The quote functions as defensive realism from a leader constantly accused of selling out the nation: he flips the accusation by implying his opponents are the ones instrumentalizing the nation.
Subtextually, it’s a warning about rhetoric’s cheapest power. “Patriot” is not a moral category but a costume anyone can put on once self-interest needs a halo. Walpole’s sting is enduring because it targets the mechanism, not the ideology: grievance plus branding equals virtue.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List







