"It is certainly safe, in view of the movement to the right of intellectuals and political thinkers, to pronounce the brain death of socialism"
About this Quote
Tebbit’s line lands like a diagnosis delivered with a politician’s relish: not merely that socialism is losing elections, but that it has suffered “brain death” - the clinical term for irrecoverable collapse. Coming from a Thatcher-era Conservative bruiser, the phrasing is strategic brutality. It doesn’t argue with socialist ideas; it declares them unfit for further debate, as if history has already switched off the life support.
The intent is twofold. First, to frame the late-20th-century drift of “intellectuals and political thinkers” rightward as the decisive arbiter of legitimacy. Tebbit isn’t just citing policy outcomes; he’s claiming custody of the prestige class. If even the people paid to think have moved right, the subtext goes, the left has nothing left but sentiment and nostalgia. Second, “safe” is doing quiet work: it signals that the verdict is now risk-free, that socialism has moved from threat to relic.
Context matters. In Britain, the 1970s’ industrial strife and the perceived failures of state management set the stage for Thatcherism’s moral and economic counter-narrative: markets as realism, unions as obstruction, collectivism as delusion. Tebbit’s jab also anticipates the coming rebrand of center-left politics (eventually New Labour): if socialism is “dead,” the only “serious” left is one that accepts market assumptions and argues over distribution at the margins.
The brilliance - and cynicism - is how it shrinks a sprawling tradition into a corpse. Once you accept that metaphor, disagreement starts to sound like denial.
The intent is twofold. First, to frame the late-20th-century drift of “intellectuals and political thinkers” rightward as the decisive arbiter of legitimacy. Tebbit isn’t just citing policy outcomes; he’s claiming custody of the prestige class. If even the people paid to think have moved right, the subtext goes, the left has nothing left but sentiment and nostalgia. Second, “safe” is doing quiet work: it signals that the verdict is now risk-free, that socialism has moved from threat to relic.
Context matters. In Britain, the 1970s’ industrial strife and the perceived failures of state management set the stage for Thatcherism’s moral and economic counter-narrative: markets as realism, unions as obstruction, collectivism as delusion. Tebbit’s jab also anticipates the coming rebrand of center-left politics (eventually New Labour): if socialism is “dead,” the only “serious” left is one that accepts market assumptions and argues over distribution at the margins.
The brilliance - and cynicism - is how it shrinks a sprawling tradition into a corpse. Once you accept that metaphor, disagreement starts to sound like denial.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Norman
Add to List
