"It is clear that this essential Christian doctrine gives a new value to human nature, to human history and to human life which is not to be found in the other great oriental religions"
About this Quote
Dawson is trying to do two things at once: elevate Christianity as a historical engine and downgrade its competitors with the polite bluntness of a mid-century European intellectual who assumes “the great oriental religions” are a coherent block. The sentence is built like a verdict (“It is clear”) rather than an argument, a rhetorical move that converts a contested claim into common sense. That’s the first tell: he’s writing less as a comparative religion scholar than as a cultural diagnostician defending the civilizational stakes of Christian doctrine.
The key phrase is “new value.” Dawson’s broader project treated Christianity not merely as a belief system but as a force that sanctified the everyday world: the person as morally significant, history as meaningful rather than cyclical, life as a drama with consequences. In the shadow of mechanized war and ideological mass politics, that framing functions as a rebuttal to modern nihilism as much as to Hinduism or Buddhism. Christianity, in his telling, doesn’t just promise salvation; it makes the human story matter in time.
The subtext is hierarchy. “Human nature, human history and human life” forms a totalizing triad, implying Christianity uniquely upgrades the entire human package. “Not to be found” is an exclusion clause that flattens vast traditions into a foil so Christianity can look like the sole custodian of personhood and progress. Even the word “oriental” signals the era: a Eurocentric taxonomy masquerading as neutral description.
Read in context, the line is less a calm comparison than a cultural argument about legitimacy: whose metaphysics can underwrite the West’s idea of the individual and of history moving somewhere, rather than endlessly repeating or dissolving into illusion.
The key phrase is “new value.” Dawson’s broader project treated Christianity not merely as a belief system but as a force that sanctified the everyday world: the person as morally significant, history as meaningful rather than cyclical, life as a drama with consequences. In the shadow of mechanized war and ideological mass politics, that framing functions as a rebuttal to modern nihilism as much as to Hinduism or Buddhism. Christianity, in his telling, doesn’t just promise salvation; it makes the human story matter in time.
The subtext is hierarchy. “Human nature, human history and human life” forms a totalizing triad, implying Christianity uniquely upgrades the entire human package. “Not to be found” is an exclusion clause that flattens vast traditions into a foil so Christianity can look like the sole custodian of personhood and progress. Even the word “oriental” signals the era: a Eurocentric taxonomy masquerading as neutral description.
Read in context, the line is less a calm comparison than a cultural argument about legitimacy: whose metaphysics can underwrite the West’s idea of the individual and of history moving somewhere, rather than endlessly repeating or dissolving into illusion.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Christopher
Add to List





